Cheese
-
Cave Aged
Quick View
-
Quick View
Pico Picandine
$9.99/EAYour cheesological French grandmother: traditional, diminutive, and adorably wrinkled. Pico could be likened to a more petite goat’s milk Camembert, but its flavor is all its own- aroma of freshly hayed barn floor alongside a deep minerality and delicate goaty tang, all wrapped up in butter and mushroom richness. Read More -
Quick View
Bijou (2-pack)
$9.99/EABased on Loire Valley classic, Crottin, these sweet little jewels are given nothing less than the royal treatment. Read More -
Quick View
Plain Goat Log - 10 ounce
$9.99/EAFresh and lemony. Perfect for your favorite recipe. Ours: stuffed into tangy peppadew. A real treat! First, milk is collected from small, local farms in Vermont. Fermentation is allowed to last a full 24 hours to make it incredibly creamy and another day's draining sets it to perfection Read More -
Quick View
Pepper Goat Log
$4.99/EAThe cheese is made with fresh goat's milk that sets overnight, is drained and then shaped into logs which are then rolled in cracked black, green and red peppercorns. Read More -
Quick View
Plain Goat Log
$4.99/EAA 25 year history and a slow, authentic process make this chevre stand out. First, milk is collected from small, local farms in Vermont. Fermentation is allowed to last a full 24 hours to make it incredibly creamy and another day's draining sets it to perfection. Read More -
Quick View
Herb Goat Log
$4.99/EAA 25 year history and a slow, authentic process make this chevre stand out. First, milk is collected from small, local farms in Vermont. Fermentation is allowed to last a full 24 hours to make it incredibly creamy and another day's draining sets it to perfection Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Selles-sur-Cher
$10.99/EAThe little black dress of goat cheese, aged in our very own caves for a thin rind, oozy creamline and exquisite texture. Perfect fit, everytime. Read More -
New
Sale
Quick View
Painted Goat Fresh Chevre
Price From:Regular Price: $11.99/EA
Special Price: $9.99/EA
We age a number of our cheeses in our caves to great effect, but Painted Goat boasts the unique distinction of having cave-aged its cheesemaker-- Ilyssa Berg, who handcrafts creamy, grassy goat cheeses in upstate New York with her partner Javier Flores, learned the art of affinage beneath our Greenwich Village store. Read More
Shop By
Country
View MoreView LessMilk Type
- Water Buffalo (1)
- Cow (2)
- Goat (30)
- Sheep (1)
Tell us what you like!
- Bold (1)
- Buttery (2)
- Comforting (1)
- Creamy (7)
- Crowd-Pleasing (4)
- Crumbly (3)
- Decadent (2)
- Delicate (12)
- Earthy (1)
- From Our Caves (7)
- Fudgy (1)
- Good for Kids (2)
- Gooey (1)
- Grassy (5)
- Herbaceous (2)
- Lingering (1)
- Magical (3)
- Mellow (4)
- Minerally (7)
- Modern (4)
- Romantic (4)
- Rustic (1)
- Salty (1)
- Serious (1)
- Silky (1)
- Smoky (1)
- Soft (6)
- Spicy (1)
- Subtle yet complex (5)
- Sweet (1)
- Tangy (8)
- Traditional (4)
- Unforgettable (2)
- Velvety (3)
- Wacky (3)
- With a story (1)
Rennet Type
Pairings
- Wheat Beers (13)
- Farmhouse Ales (3)
- Belgian-Style Ales (2)
- Pinot Noir (3)
- Merlot (2)
- Syrah and Shiraz (2)
- Tempranillo (1)
- Pinot Grigio (1)
- Sauvignon Blanc (4)
- Chenin Blanc (6)
- Rose (8)
- Cider (4)
- Scotch (1)
- Gin (2)
