Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheese

Cheese

Grid View List View

1-9 of 34

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  1. Cave Aged Out of stock C-Local Quick View

    C-Local

    $29.99/EA
    Murray's cave manager Brian Ralph first hatched the idea for C-Local cheese on his commute to work, on - you guessed it - the C train. Read More
  2. Cave Aged Kinderhook Creek Quick View

    Old Chatham Sheepherding Company
    Kinderhook Creek

    $24.99/EA
    Kinderhook Creek is the newest darling from New York's Old Chatham Sheepherding Company. Made from 100% pure East Friesian sheep's milk, we mature this cheese to tangy, mushroomy perfection in the caves below our shop. Read More
  3. Cave Aged Valentine Quick View

    Ancient Heritage Farm
    Valentine

    $14.99/EA
    It's a party! Valentine looks like a wee pillar of cloud and tastes like a sheep's milk cheesecake - the luscious, airy interior easily gives way between your teeth as waves of herbaceous, grassy flavor wash over your senses. What better way to celebrate spring than a little bit of cake? Read More
  4. St. Stephen Quick View

    Four Fat Fowl
    St. Stephen

    $16.99/EA
    Hudson Valley creamery, Four Fat Fowl, took its name from a colonial rental fee charged by the last landlord of Rensselaerswyck (what’s now Rensselaer county”), which amounted to a day’s labor, including ten to twenty bushels of wheat. Their small, bloomy rounds are delicately buttery, with hints of sun-dried wheat and sweet cream beneath its pillowy rind, making St. Stephen a true expression of local terroir. Serve with local, NY honey, fresh berries and something bubbly to drink. Read More
  5. Perail Quick View

    Fromagerie Papillon
    Perail

    $8.99/EA
    We’ve got butterflies just thinking about these creamy little rounds from Fromagerie Papillon, France’s renowned producer of Roquefort. Traditionally made when the herd wasn’t producing large enough quantities of milk for Roquefort, the soft-ripened wheels are crafted from pasteurized ewe’s milk in the rocky hillsides of Causses. Similar to Brebirousse d’Argental, or an unwashed Reblochon, the sheep’s rich milk imparts a sweet, sheepy character to the buttery-smooth paste that makes an unparalleled pair with bubbly wines. Read More
  6. Blue Earth Quick View

    Alemar Cheese Company
    Blue Earth

    $32.99/LB
    Financial-service-man-turned-cheese-maker, Keith Adams, named his cheese company by combining his two daughters, Alex and Mari and began making fine, heartland cheeses back in 2009. Blue Earth is the latest addition to his growing line of grass-fed, pasteurized cow’s milk cheeses. It’s an all-American brie-style round with grassy, buttery flavors that permeate from snowy rind to oozing cream line and down through its rich, fudgy center. Read More
  7. Nuvola di Pecora Quick View

    Nuvola di Pecora

    $23.99/EA
    This semisoft sheep's milk cheese sports a meadow of bright yellow mold on it's unconventionally square rind. Deep, earthy straw notes compliment it's light sweetness, and a sheepy tang makes this Italian beauty linger on your palate. Read More
  8. Out of stock Mt. Alice Quick View

    Von Trapp
    Mt. Alice

    $26.99/EA
    All the girls love Alice, and everyone loves Mt. Alice. The talented Von Trapp brothers, Dan and Sebastian, make this camembert-style cheese on their farm in Waitsfield, VT, which has been in the family for generations. Not only is Mt. Alice farmstead-made, but it's certified organic to boot! The soft , downy rind gives way to a creamy interior that is pure buttery goodness, with just a hint of mushroomy earthiness to keep things interesting. Read More
  9. Camembert Quick View

    Camembert

    $12.99/EA
    Temptation lives in a round, wooden box. This petit fromage is deliciously nutty and dewy when ripe, with the aroma of wet rope. A fully ripe specimen displays a melting straw-colored paste with assertive mushroom flavors. Read More

Grid View List View

1-9 of 34

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4