Visitor Monitoring
Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheese

Cheese

Grid View List View

1-9 of 25

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  1. Cave Aged Humboldt Fog Quick View

    Cypress Grove
    Humboldt Fog

    $29.99/LB
    You may be expecting a cheesecake, but it's really one of the most famous American chevres. Mary Keehn from Humboldt County, CA, makes this tangy treat with a beautiful bloomy rind and a line of vegetable ash bisecting each wheel. 2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  2. Cave Aged Haystack Peak Quick View

    Haystack Mountain
    Haystack Peak

    $18.99/EA
    The most delicious foothill we’ve seen, tucked beneath the shadows of the Rockies in Longmont, Colorado, Haystack Peak bursts with aromas of wet stone and flavors of sautéed mushrooms and cultured butter. Read More
  3. Cato Corner Hooligan Quick View

    Cato Corner Farm
    Cato Corner Hooligan

    $39.99/EA
    Our Cavemaster has reported numerous instances of Cato Corner Hooligan roughhousing Raclette and getting fresh with Fontina, but it’s a risk we’re willing to accept from this pungent, beefy tomme... Read More
  4. Cave Aged Manchester Quick View

    Consider Bardwell Farm
    Manchester

    $32.99/LB
    This is one feisty goat! Brine washing in our caves imparts a pungent kick to its paste, and the flavor swells to a peppery bite on the finish.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  5. Cave Aged Harbison Quick View

    Cellars at Jasper Hill
    Harbison

    $23.99/EA
    The baby of the Jasper Hill family, born from the marriage between Winnemere and Moses Sleeper. A cradle of spruce bark imparts a pine-y flavor to the oozy, floral paste. Read More
  6. Cave Aged Hudson Red Quick View

    Twin Maple Farm
    Hudson Red

    $29.99/LB
    Perfect when you want a little funk without a shark-like bite. Gentle reddish rind gives way to a velvety paste that has just the right amount of brown-sugary sweetness. An Upstate delight. Read More
  7. Cave Aged Landaff Quick View

    Landaff Creamery
    Landaff

    $28.99/LB
    Inspiration, found Caer-fully. An American original which, like its Welsh counterpart, is exceptionally easy to eat enormous quantities of, whilst drinking beer. Read More
  8. Cave Aged Tumbleweed Quick View

    5 Spoke Creamery
    Tumbleweed

    $24.99/LB
    If farmhouse Cheddar and French Cantal took a roll in the weeds you'd get this little square. Read More
  9. Truffle Tremor Quick View

    Cypress Grove
    Truffle Tremor

    $34.99/LB
    Truffles, yes. Gimmicky, never. America's most famous goaty cake of a cheese flecked with fungal goodness. Just say yes. Read More

Grid View List View

1-9 of 25

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3