Cheese
-
Quick View
Dunbarton Blue
$29.99/LBFourth generation cheesemaker Chris Roelli committed the equivalent of blue cheese heresy by piercing his cheese and then pressing it to inhibit the mold growth. The result is Dunbarton Blue, a sort of blue-veined cheddar that's potent yet approachable. In a typical blue, the pierce holes introduce air that allows the desirable mold to proliferate within the cheese. By pressing it, Chris halts the process, developing a distinct but subtle bluing that hints at piquancy without punching you in the face. A unique and fantastic cheese from a true American cheesemaking family. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Hudson Red
$29.99/LBPerfect when you want a little funk without a shark-like bite. Gentle reddish rind gives way to a velvety paste that has just the right amount of brown-sugary sweetness. An Upstate delight. Read More -
Sale
Cave Aged
Quick View
-
Quick View
Black River Blue
$9.99/LBA classic American blue from the North Hendren Cheese Cooperative which has been making cheese for 80 years. The recipe for this blue is well-guarded, and for good reason! The texture is slightly softer than butter- a nice creamy backdrop for the bright blue flavor. Read More -
Quick View
Cato Corner Hooligan
$39.99/EAOur Cavemaster has reported numerous instances of Cato Corner Hooligan roughhousing Raclette and getting fresh with Fontina, but it’s a risk we’re willing to accept from this pungent, beefy tomme... Read More -
Quick View
Smokey Blue
$26.99/LBIts true! This special version of Oregon Blue Vein is cold smoked for 16 hours over Northwest -grown hazelnut shells. The result is a balance of sweet caramel and hazelnut flavors that contrasts deliciously with the sharp bite of the blue veining. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Bayley Hazen Blue
$28.99/LBThe Northeast Kingdom of Vermont: rumored to have more cows than people. Taste their bounty in this blue: dry, complex, and nutty, with a hint of licorice. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
-
Cave Aged
Quick View
Consider Bardwell
Manchester$31.99/LBThis is one feisty goat! Brine washing in our caves imparts a pungent kick to its paste, and the flavor swells to a peppery bite on the finish.
2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
Shop By
Category
- Blue (6)
- Manchego & Sheepy (1)
- One of a Kind (3)
- Stinky (3)
- Cave Aged (5)
Milk Type
Price
- $0.00 - $20.00 (1)
- $20.00 - $40.00 (11)
Tell us what you like!
- Blue (5)
- Bold (2)
- Buttery (2)
- Challenging (3)
- Creamy (2)
- Crowd-Pleasing (3)
- Crumbly (1)
- Decadent (1)
- For a special occasion (2)
- From Our Caves (3)
- Fruity (1)
- Fudgy (3)
- Funky (4)
- Good for Kids (1)
- Grassy (2)
- Herbaceous (1)
- Lingering (4)
- Magical (1)
- Meaty (3)
- Mellow (1)
- Minerally (2)
- Modern (3)
- Nutty (2)
- Rustic (1)
- Salty (2)
- Savory (1)
- Serious (2)
- Smoky (1)
- Soft (1)
- Spicy (1)
- Stinky (2)
- Sweet (1)
- Tangy (1)
- Unforgettable (3)
- Vegetal (1)
- Wacky (1)
Rennet Type
