Cheese
-
Cave Aged
Quick View
Vermont Butter and Cheese Creamery
Torus$10.99/EALooks like a donut, tastes like a cheesy croissant—buttered paste, yeasty rind, and a hint of minerality from its time in our caves. Read More -
Quick View
Westfield Farm Capri
$14.99/LBThe freshest of the fresh, made weekly only a few hours away by Westfield Farms. Clean, lactic and creamy, this whole-milk goat cheese is naturally the lightest in the case. Lean, mean, and local? Sold! Read More -
Quick View
Young Goat Gouda
$16.99/LBFool your non-goat-cheese-loving friends with this mild sweetie that reveals minimal goatiness. Palate-pleasing texture, pretty pale paste. Made in Holland, of pasteurized goat's milk. Read More -
Quick View
Drunken Goat
$21.99/LBSoon after it's made, this goat's milk cheese from Murcia, Spain is dunked in a barrel of Paso Doble red wine for a full 48 hours. The rind turns an appetizing shade of purple, while the interior remains a bright shade of white and gains a mild fruity flavor. Read More -
Quick View
French Goat Feta
$18.99/LBAlthough the French have only been making feta for 25 years, the U.S. imports more than from Greece, Bulgaria and all the Balkans combined. French feta is aged in salted whey, not just brine, which imparts added creaminess. Made of pasteurized goats' milk. Read More -
New
Sale
Quick View
Painted Goat Fresh Chevre
Price From:Regular Price: $11.99/EA
Special Price: $9.99/EA
We age a number of our cheeses in our caves to great effect, but Painted Goat boasts the unique distinction of having cave-aged its cheesemaker-- Ilyssa Berg, who handcrafts creamy, grassy goat cheeses in upstate New York with her partner Javier Flores, learned the art of affinage beneath our Greenwich Village store. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Pata de Cabra
$24.99/LBPungent, tangy, aromatic and shaped like the leg of the animal whose milk it is made with. Yum! A washed-rind variety made in very small quantities. When young, it is fruity and refined with a robust ''kick'' at the finish. With a little extra age, it becomes more pungent and powerful. Read More -
Quick View
Blanc Bleu Tambour
$49.99/LBDon't be fooled by the name. The bleu here refers to the mold that grows on the rind. The paste itself is a sparkling white, and the raw goats milk imparts a clean, but complex flavor. Pair with a crisp Chablis. Read More -
New
Quick View
Angel Food
$16.99/EAAmidst the sprawling soybeans and copious cornfields of central Illinois, if you listen closely you can hear an occasional bleat or baa and can sometimes catch the scent of just-formed curd on a warm breeze. Here you’ll find Prairie Fruits Farm, owned by soil scientists Wes Jarrel and Leslie Cooperband, just a few miles away from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, where people take farming so seriously that they built their library below ground so as not to block the on-campus corn plots from sunlight. Read More




