Cheese
-
Quick View
-
Cave Aged
Quick View
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged
$32.99/LBA firm raw cow milk cheese with intense fruit and olive flavors.
2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Pata de Cabra
$24.99/LBPungent, tangy, aromatic and shaped like the leg of the animal whose milk it is made with. Yum! A washed-rind variety made in very small quantities. When young, it is fruity and refined with a robust ''kick'' at the finish. With a little extra age, it becomes more pungent and powerful. Read More -
Quick View
Alsatian Munster
$26.99/LBWhile true Alsatian Munster isn't street legal in the US on account of it being raw and under 60 days, this pasteurized version does a pretty mean impression. Read More -
Quick View
Rogue Creamery
Caveman Blue$32.99/LBIntroduced in 2009, this one just might be the best of the Rogue creamery bunch. Thankfully, its mellow spice probably won't club you over the head and drag you back to the cave. Read More -
New
Quick View
Cabot Creamery
Murray's Select Vermont Cheddar$12.99/LBFrom Vermont’s cheddar experts at Cabot, a classic cheddar, just for Murray's. It’s a nutty classic that fits the grill—get it now at this sweet introductory price and it fits the bill, too! Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
-
Quick View
Gorgonzola Cremificato
$17.99/LBMorning milk makes melting blues. Heavy cream and Italian cultures also have something to do with the thick creaminess of the 'sweet' gorgonzola. Serve with honeyed pears for dessert- and never look back... Read More -
Quick View
Klaverkaas Kaamps Estate Gouda
$19.99/LBAn authentic farmers cheese made in the Netherlands for generations, this is Gouda as intended: fresh, buttery cow’s milk with a savory, nutty bite. The name Klaverkaas, or ‘clover cheese’, refers to a diet rich in green clover that the pampered Holstein-Friesian herd enjoys day in and day out. Read More
Shop By
Category
- Blue (3)
- Brie & Creamy (2)
- Cheddar (2)
- Fresh & Chevre (2)
- Gouda (3)
- Manchego & Sheepy (1)
- One of a Kind (3)
- Swiss & Nutty (11)
- Stinky (6)
- Smoked & Flavored (1)
- Tommes (2)
- Best Sellers (8)
- Cave Aged (16)
- Sale (3)
- New (3)
Country
- USA (11)
- France (8)
- Italy (4)
- The Netherlands (2)
- Switzerland (4)
- Spain (2)
- United Kingdom and Ireland (2)
Milk Type
Tell us what you like!
- Blue (2)
- Bold (8)
- Buttery (4)
- Caramelly (2)
- Challenging (3)
- Comforting (4)
- Creamy (1)
- Crowd-Pleasing (8)
- Decadent (1)
- Delicate (1)
- Earthy (2)
- For a special occasion (5)
- From Our Caves (10)
- Fruity (2)
- Fudgy (4)
- Funky (4)
- Good for Kids (4)
- Gooey (2)
- Grassy (4)
- Hard (1)
- Lingering (7)
- Magical (5)
- Meaty (9)
- Mellow (4)
- Minerally (2)
- Modern (2)
- Mushroomy (1)
- Nutty (6)
- Rustic (3)
- Salty (1)
- Savory (7)
- Serious (3)
- Sharp (1)
- Smoky (1)
- Soft (3)
- Stinky (6)
- Subtle yet complex (1)
- Sweet (1)
- Tangy (1)
- Traditional (4)
- Unforgettable (5)
- Velvety (1)
- Wacky (2)
- With a story (2)
Rennet Type
