Visitor Monitoring
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.



Grid View List View

  1. Ewephoria Sheep Milk Gouda Quick View

    Ewephoria Sheep Milk Gouda

    If you're feeling vulnerable, then definitely don't have a taste of this sweet, crunchy novelty. Seriously - no one has ever said no. Read More
  2. Asiago D'Allevo Quick View

    Asiago D'Allevo

    With flavors reminiscent of the fragrances of yeast and dried fruit, this firm raw cow milk cheese starts out sweet and becomes more savory and piquant as it ages. From Italy's Po River Valley. Read More
  3. Beato de Tabara Quick View

    Beato de Tabara

    We love a wonderful cheese with a juicy story. Santiago Lucas Leon was inspired by the illustrated manuscripts of the monastery of San Martin de Tábara. So he set out to make a brand new cheese with medieval soul. He and his sons raise goats in the Sierra de la Culebra, and nurture the raw milk into this cylinder of semi-firm goodness. Beato de Tábara tastes both of earthy monastic cellar and fresh pasture—sweet yet goaty, earthy, and bright. Thank you, cheesemaking (and cheese-drawing) monks. Fantastic with ripe pear and a glass of crisp Riesling, or rich Tempranillo. Read More
  4. New Old Chatham Vanilla Yogurt (16 oz) Quick View

    Old Chatham Vanilla Yogurt (16 oz)

    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  5. Danby Quick View


    A hard, extra-aged, raw goat milk cheese, inspired by Italian sardos like Piave and Asiago. These large wheels are aged a minimum of six months. It's pure, dense white paste reminds us of our local Danby, VT marble, made famous for its use building our nation's capital and monuments. Ideal for grating over pasta or a nice sharp snack. Read More
  6. Old Chatham Plain Yogurt (16 oz) Quick View

    Old Chatham Plain Yogurt (16 oz)

    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  7. New Old Chatham Yogurt Case (12/6 oz Containers) Quick View

    Old Chatham Yogurt Case (12/6 oz Containers)

    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  8. Pria Azul Quick View

    Pria Azul

    This rustic beauty hails from Asturias, in the misty mountains hugging the Northern coast of Spain. Pria Azul is a unique blend of 50% cow, 40% sheep and 10% goat’s milk, and is a far cry from other aggressive Spanish blue cheeses. The fresh wheels are both pierced to create bluing and also smoked, then aged to create a gorgeous natural rind. This process results in a incredibly creamy and milky paste, subtely gamey and smokey, with a perfect flavor trifecta of sweet, salty and savory. A must with port and luscious dark chocolate. Read More
  9. Picon Bejes Tresviso Quick View

    Picon Bejes Tresviso

    Miguel Angel and Francisco Javier Campo are brothers with cheesemaking in their blood—their parents made cheese in Cantabria, in the north of Spain, as did their grandparents, and their great-grandparents. This raw cow’s milk blue harnesses that rich tradition. It’s been name-protected since 1994, and won an impressively long list of awards. Piquant teal veins zigzag through Picon’s rustic, crumbly paste. It’s the ultimate piquante Spanish blue—bold and balanced, salty and refined. Serve on baguette with a drizzle of honey or apple jam for an elegant appetizer. Pair with sherry or tawny port for dessert. Read More
  10. Mahon Meloussa Quick View

    Mahon Meloussa

    A Spanish classic made since Roman times, in Minorca in the Balearic Islands. Mahon gets its briny, punchy character from the Menorcan winds blanketing the island’s grass in fresh sea salt. The DOP regulations allow for a maximum of 5% sheep milk to be used—a throwback to when farmers needed to use whatever milk they had on hand. Mahon DOP Meloussa Semi is made from 95% raw cow’s milk and 5% raw sheep’s milk, and the latter delivers boozy fruitiness and just a hint of briny tang. Serve with juicy figs, marcona almonds, and a hoppy IPA, a fruity cider, or a spicy Rioja. Read More
  11. Arzua Ulloa Quick View

    Arzua Ulloa

    On the banks of the Ulluo River in Galicia, where Arzua Ulloa is made and loved, it is sometimes called queixo do pays, meaning "cheese of the land". The name-protected beauty is crafted from milk from Rubia Gallega, Frisian and Alpine Brown cows that graze on the area’s green pastures. It’s aged for a mere two weeks—the pasteurized cheese is mild yet complex, redolent of freshly churned butter and proofing bread dough. Arzua Ulloa’s natural, straw yellow rind makes way to reveal a satiny ivory paste, smooth and unrelentingly creamy. Arzua Ulloa is a superstar melter. Make a no-joke grilled cheese, with or without quince paste (we vote with). Or serve with honey and marcona almonds, beside a crisp Albariño. Read More
  12. Bauma Madurat Quick View

    Bauma Madurat

    Toni Chueca is a pioneer. He started making gorgeous farmstead goat’s cheeses in Catalunya in 1980, in a region devoid of goat’s milk cheese. Since then, the cheese has reached the apex of its deliciousness. These days, it abounds—especially Toni’s Madurat, a friendly, pasteurized log covered in veggie ash. The cheese is dense and smooth, with bright, lemony notes and a mushroomy mellowness. It’s genius crumbled in salads and omelets, or served beside anchovies and olives for an elegant appetizer. Pop open a bottle of lively Cava, or a crisp Pale Ale. Read More
  13. Old Chatham Yogurt Quick View

    Old Chatham Yogurt

    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  14. Kinderhook Creek Mini Quick View

    Kinderhook Creek Mini

    Kinderhook Creek is a pure sheep's milk, soft-ripened cheese. This bloomy rind surrounds a wonderfully creamy, earthy center that will become oozy upon reaching its peak. This is a specialty item and will be shipped separately from your order. We generally ship these on the Tuesday after your order is place. Trust us, it’s worth the wait! Read More
  15. Jarlsberg Quick View


    We all know this nutty cheese with the buttery texture and large eye-holes. Jerry (of Tom and Jerry fame) would find a hiding space in this “classic” Swiss-style cheese. Great for parties or baiting traps. Read More
  16. Fiacco di Capra Quick View

    Fiacco di Capra

    Coming soon... Read More
  17. New Mystic, Melville Quick View

    Mystic, Melville

    Melville is a brand new cheese, from a brand new cheesemaking operation in Mystic, Connecticut, and we’re excited about it. Here’s why you should be, too: a white whale, it’s the rare American super-fresh Stracchino cheese, inspired by the Northern Italian style, which is all about smoothness, pliability and awesome meltability. Melville’s namesake is Herman Melville—homage to the texture of the soft, luxuriously buttery square of cow’s milk cheese. It’s a supple, silky “singularly fatty globule of pure deliciousness,” and a mere few weeks old. It’s a revelation with sweet tomatoes, or atop pizza and pasta, a bottle of Champagne highly recommended. Read More
  18. New Hamden Quick View


    Named for the next hamlet over from Vulto creamery in Walton, NY, Hamden is cheese gone wild. Its birth story: cheesemaker Jos Vulto took a few wheels from their Ouleout batch and let them free to develop their own natural rind. Lo and behold: a rich diversity of molds and yeasts on the rind for plenty of earthy crunch. Its semi-soft paste tastes of the valley in spring—fresh milk, just-cut grass, hay. Hamden is Tomme de Savoie’s Hudson Valley soul sister. It begs for farmhouse ale, a crusty baguette, and ripe stone fruit. Jos Vulto left his career as a metal-worker to follow the siren-call of cheesemaking. He started out in his Brooklyn apartment, crafting cheese in his kitchen and aging his wheels beneath the sidewalk. In 2012, he opened a real-deal operation in New York’s western Catskills. We’re happy he did. He sources milk his neighbor, farmer Dan Finn’s herd of Holstein and Jersey cows and makes raw milk beauties full of charisma and depth. Read More
  19. New St. Mark's Quick View

    St. Mark's

    St. Mark’s is our New York City take on a French classic from the Rhône-Alpes, St. Marcellin. The little, mushroomy disks of cow’s milk goodness were Louis XI’s favorite. Sadly, real St. Marcellin is no longer available in the USA. Happily…St. Mark’s is here! Read More
  20. Grazier's Edge Quick View

    The Lone Grazer Creamery
    Grazier's Edge

    A pungent delight from Minnesota's The Lone Grazer Creamery, Grazier's Edge is handcrafted with grass-fed milk from two local farms and washed in St. Paul's 11 Wells Rye Whiskey. Strong yet approachable, with distinct notes of creamed sweet corn and grass, this is best enjoyed with a stiff glass of bourbon. Read More
  21. One Stop Accoutrements Quick View

    One Stop Accoutrements

    The icing on the (cheese)cake. Read More
  22. Extra Mature Cheddar Quick View

    Grafton Village Cheese
    Extra Mature Cheddar

    As the years and years unfold, complex flavors emerge: they’re brawny, funky, and have plenty of bite. The texture is crumbly and crunchy. Pair with something bold like a California Cabernet or a frothy Porter. Read More
  23. Clothbound Cheddar Quick View

    Grafton Village Cheese
    Clothbound Cheddar

    Milk from select Vermont dairy farms gets cheddared, wrapped in cheesecloth and lovingly matured. A crumbly-creamy wheel, redolent of hazelnuts and meaty mushrooms. Enjoy with a glass of Oloroso Sherry or an off-dry Riesling. Read More
  24. Nancy's Camembert Quick View

    Nancy's Camembert

    Old Chatham's Iconic Nancy's Hudson Valley Camembert is a lush blend of sheep's milk, cow's milk and cow's cream. This soft-ripened cheese is lusciously creamy, rich and buttery. Weighing in at 2.5 pounds this wheel is perfect for your next party! Read More
  25. Sage Cheddar Quick View

    Grafton Village Cheese
    Sage Cheddar

    Grafton Village Cheese makes beloved cheddar from the raw Jersey milk of local Vermont farmers. This delightful creation is seasoned with Dalmatian sage for fresh, herbal flavor. Awesome melted in an egg and sausage sandwich, or make an herby potato gratin. Read More
  26. Garlic Cheddar Quick View

    Grafton Village Cheese
    Garlic Cheddar

    Garlic met Grafton Village Cheese’s classic Vermont Cheddar. Sparks flew. Now they are happily married in this balanced cheese—a vibrant, perfectly pungent treat. Read More
  27. Maple Smoked Cheddar Quick View

    Grafton Village Cheese
    Maple Smoked Cheddar

    Price From:
    A four-hour visit to smoldering Maplewood imparts smoky, campfire flavors to this award-winning Cheddar. Melt on a roast beef sandwich, stuff a quesadilla, or snack away with apples and crusty bread. Read More
  28. 1 Year Aged Cheddar Quick View

    Grafton Village Cheese
    1 Year Aged Cheddar

    Price From:
    Creamy and rich, with the comforting appeal of an old-school farmhouse cheddar—sweet apple and brown butter flavors go down easy. A great snack with ripe pears; perfect for melting on chili. Open a crisp Riesling, or a bright Pilsner. Read More
  29. Murray's Mascarpone Quick View

    Murray's Mascarpone

    Creamier than butter. Silkier than ricotta. Richer than your favorite triple crème. A tub of magic. This fresh Italian treat is a dessert superstar, perfect for stuffing cannoli and making tiramisu. Drizzle with honey and serve with whatever fresh fruits make you happy. Mascarpone also shines in savory dishes: plop into pasta, mashed potatoes or tomato soup for no-joke lavishness. 8.8 oz. Read More
  30. Collier's Welsh Cheddar Quick View

    Collier's Welsh Cheddar

    Bold like its namesake the colliers, or coal miners, this cheddar is made in the Welsh mountains of Denbighshire.  Aged and robust, with a lingering sweetness and crystalline crunch, this cheddar is a friend of any beer; we're partial to a pint of bitter blond ale. Read More
  31. Great Hill Blue Quick View

    Great Hill Blue

    Great Hill Dairy makes one and only one cheese beauty: Great Hill Blue. They craft their rindless, clean-flavored blue in Buzzard Bay, 50 miles south of Boston, with unpasteurized, unhomogenized milk from their own Guernseys, plus Jersey and Holstein cows from neighboring farms. Inhale: toasty, salty aromas. Get ready for bright, acidic tanginess, with just a hint of peppery bite. Great Hill Blue’s not shy about salt and zip. Crumbly and curdy, it shines melted on a burger or crumbled on a wedge salad. Or serve post-dinner with a Tawny Port or a fruity Icewine to curb all that brawn and bite. Read More
  32. New Chevrotin Quick View


    Seal Cove Farm’s rounds of grana-style goat’s milk goodness are bright and briny, just like the creamery’s namesake, even if they’re made (just a bit) inland. They are brined and aged for more than two months for a crumbly texture and a wallop of sweet, just-a-bit floral, yogurty flavor. It’s a perfect texture for crumbling over pasta or roasted veggies, or snacking on beside a crisp cider or a minerally Riesling. Seal Cove Farm began in 1976 in Lamoine, Maine with a pair of impressive dairy goats. “Each spring, we enjoy watching the newborn baby goats frolic with their mothers, knowing that with a happy life on our farm, these goats will create better tasting milk for our cheeses,” they say. Happy goats, happy cheese. Read More
  33. Cave Aged Project X Quick View

    Project X

    From the hidden laboratories deep within Murray’s Caves, our newest experiment emerges: Project X! A collaboration with Spring Brook farm in Vermont, this raw cow’s milk tomme takes its inspiration from the rugged mountain cheeses of Italy, with our own Northeast twist. We coat these wheels with a generous helping of herbaceous fennel pollen, followed by repeated bathing in Gewurztraminer from New York’s Finger Lakes. The result is incredible: lusciously moist, with flavors of roasted walnuts, cocoa and anise. Equally at home on a cheese board or melted in pasta, with a glass of Alpine-style white wine. Read More
  34. Weinkase Lagrein Quick View

    Weinkase Lagrein

    Don't be duped by the name; in German it means 'wine cheese,' but this unusual tomme is actually from northern Italy. Soaked in Lagrein wine and spices, it's creamy, lightly peppery, and a bit garlicky; like super-fancy beef jerky. Read More
  35. Cave Aged Kinderhook Creek Quick View

    Old Chatham Sheepherding Company
    Kinderhook Creek

    Kinderhook Creek is the newest darling from New York's Old Chatham Sheepherding Company. Made from 100% pure East Friesian sheep's milk, we mature this cheese to tangy, mushroomy perfection in the caves below our shop. Read More
  36. Flory's Truckle Quick View

    Milton Creamery
    Flory's Truckle

    Milton Creamery worked hand-in-hand with the Flory Family of Jamesport, Missouri to develop this aged clothbound cheddar. It has a peppery aroma, a dry crumbly texture and a rich grassy flavor. Read More
  37. Cave Aged Alpha Tolman Quick View

    Cellars at Jasper Hill
    Alpha Tolman

    Alpha Tolman is made using the traditional Alpine methods of cooking and pressing the curds during cheesemaking to chieve a tight, elastic texture and robust, complex flavors. The wheels are then washed with brine to infuse them with a funky edge. Read More
  38. Dill Havarti Quick View

    Roth Kase
    Dill Havarti

    Ahh, this is what decades of experience from two cheesemakers in Wisconsin produces. Creamy, subtle, tender, fresh tasting dill in this pasteurized cow's cheese. Read More
  39. Original Blue Quick View

    Point Reyes
    Original Blue

    The Giacomini Family, third generation dairy farmers in West Marin, CA, have been making farmstead products since 1959. They converted their milk into cheese in 2000 and introduced Original Blue™, California’s iconic classic style blue cheese. Known for its extra creamy texture and bright milk flavors up front with a pepper pungency in the finish, Original Blue is great drizzled with honey, on a steak or melted into pasta. Read More
  40. Jalapeno Jack Quick View

    Jalapeno Jack

    This Jack is packing heat— fresh red and green Jalapeños add a kick to buttery cheese made with milk from a 16-farm cooperative in Wisconsin. Bursting with south-of-the-border flavor, eat immediately or melt over nachos or burgers. Read More
  41. Murray's English Cheddar Quick View

    Murray's English Cheddar

    Fresh cow’s milk from the lush fields of England’s West Country-- home to King Arthur, Camelot and centuries of cheddar-making history--is carefully crafted into this savory cheddar with an unusual depth of tangy, sweet and nutty flavors, developed after 16 months of age. Sidle up to the round table with a hunk of cheddar and a pint of blond ale. Read More
  42. New The French Connection Quick View

    The French Connection

    Bring the sidewalk café to their home with savory, sophisticated flavors and vibrant cheeses that will take you for a walk down memory boulevard. Read More
  43. Marcel Petite Comte - 2 Year Quick View

    Marcel Petite Comte - 2 Year

    Aged for 2 years which is the max the affineur will allow. The enormous wheels of raw cows' milk have a firm texture, leaving flavors that can range from dense (smoke and onions), to sweeter, with notes of chocolate and hazelnuts. Read More
  44. Chabichou Quick View


    After over a millennium of development, your rind would be a little wrinkled, too. This pasteurized goat’s milk cylinder—called a “bonde” in the world of French cheesemaking—made its debut in eighth-century France, just south of the Loire in Poitou. Read More
  45. Bijou (2-pack) Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Bijou (2-pack)

    Based on Loire Valley classic, Crottin, these sweet little jewels are given nothing less than the royal treatment. Read More
  46. Castelrosso Quick View


    This tri-layered Italian wonder is a cross between a smooth, creamy-driven French tomme and a firm, curdy English cheddar. Read More
  47. Aged Manchego Quick View

    Aged Manchego

    Perhaps Spain’s most famous cheese, Manchego is a D.O. (Denominacion de Origen) protected cheese, meaning the traditional recipe must use 100% Manchega sheep milk. The breed has proven sturdy enough over the centuries to traverse the rocky, arid central plateau region of La Mancha – where cows just can’t hang. Read More
  48. Chevre d'Argental Quick View

    Chevre d'Argental

    Why the hexagon? Perhaps the perfect simplicity of this pasteurized goat's milk cheese from Lyon had the cheesemakers worried. No gimmicks necessary, in our opinion. A creamy to runny interior with a rind as tender and fine as any Brie. Read More
  49. Persille de Rambouillet Quick View

    La Tremblaye
    Persille de Rambouillet

    Goaty, blue and creamy, this cheese is new to us and is an immediate cult classic among our mongers. It is made by the same traditional farmstead cheesemaker that produces our Brie de Fermier and has just as much complexity. With a pleasing peppery salinity and a finish that stretches to infinity, this cheese will wow goat and blue lovers alike. Try with an off-dry sparking rose or a port-based cocktail. Read More
  50. Vermont Creamery Goat Crumbles Quick View

    Vermont Creamery Goat Crumbles

    Crumbled Goat Cheese is a 100% all-natural goat cheese made with Vermont Creamery’s award-winning Chevre recipe and blended with high-quality herbs and dried fruit. Read More
  51. Cave Aged The Other Stephen Quick View

    The Other Stephen

    We love St. Stephen. These heavenly little discs are 75% butterfat, with a decadent flavor profile that hits on notes of fresh cream and butter-soaked mushrooms. But this particular St. Stephen is no Saint – this one comes bathed in Short, Dark & Handsome, an American stout from Other Half Brewing in Brooklyn. At 7.00% ABV, the beer wash brings some rowdiness to the cheese, imparting notes of roasted coffee beans, dark cocoa, hops and flowers, with a nice salty finish that might just get you a little rowdy yourself. Read More
  52. Murray's Brie Quick View

    Murray's Brie

    When the mushroomy, garlicky intensity of Fromage de Meaux is more than you want, pasteurized French Brie offers a creamy and mild, buttery flavor familiar to all who have purchased most other well-known brands. This one is a true double creme 60% brie, meaning it is 60% butterfat in dry matter (but 100% brie). Sturdy and economical enough for baking in pastry or slicing for artsy sammies. Light bodied, fruity whites are best for pairing. Read More
  53. Bourbon Bellavitano Quick View

    Bourbon Bellavitano

    This bourbon-bathed beauty is made exclusively for Murray’s by Satori Cheese out of Wisconsin. It tastes like a cross between Cheddar and Parmigiano-Reggiano, with a crumbly exterior and a complex flavor profile revealing creamy, nutty notes. It’s then washed in Kentucky bourbon, infusing a sweet and smoky woodiness on the outside with a strong, milky saltiness on the inside. After the bourbon shower, the cheese is aged for five months until peak flavor is reached. Bright, vibrant and scarce, this labor-of-love is a true specialty. Read More
  54. Quesuco Ahumado de Liebana Quick View

    Quesuco Ahumado de Liebana

    Hailing from the northern coast of Spain, this DOP cow’s milk tomme is lightly smoked over juniper branches for 36 hours. Perfectly balanced notes of smoke and freshly cultured butter, an instant classic with spicy chorizo and grilled bread. Read More
  55. Montealva Quick View


    A citrusy barnburner from Southwest Spain, Montealva uses milk from a rare breed of Andalucian goats. Dense and flakey, with a flavor redolent of fresh-squeezed lemons, this cheese is a must with a glass of fino sherry. Read More
  56. Cave Aged Cornelia Quick View

    Cave Master Reserve

    An homage to the original location of Murray’s, Cornelia arrives just-formed from Point Reyes Farmstead. Pampered first in our sauna-like washed rind cave, then finished in our natural rind cave, she develops a sublimely buttery, rich paste with a roasted peanut finish. Cornelia is perfect on her own, but she totally digs the company of a medium-bodied red and bold charcuterie. Read More
  57. Murray's Select Parmigiano Reggiano Quick View

    Murray's Select Parmigiano Reggiano

    A distinctive buttery aroma hints at the barrage of nutty sweetness and spice followed by a salt-caramel finish. We’re quite sure that the squat 80 pound kegs of cheese are made from raw, partially skimmed milk in Parma - thanks to strict D.O.P regulations. We choose 24 month wheels; any younger and we miss the intensity, any older and the salt and sandy texture overwhelms. Those white specks there are clusters of amino acids. They reflect proper aging and create a delightful crunchy texture. You can put parm on anything, but a traditional approach might involve ribbons of proscuitto and a swirl of Lambrusco. Read More
  58. Nuvola di Pecora Quick View

    Nuvola di Pecora

    This semisoft sheep's milk cheese sports a meadow of bright yellow mold on it's unconventionally square rind. Deep, earthy straw notes compliment it's light sweetness, and a sheepy tang makes this Italian beauty linger on your palate. Read More
  59. Ouleout Quick View

    Vulto Creamery

    Ouleout is named after a creek which flows through Delaware County, where Vulto Creamery is located. Ouleout is an Algonquin name meaning "a continuing voice." A raw milk, grass-fed cow's milk round in the vein of Ardrahan and Munster, Ouleout is medicinal and briny, with strong notes of roasted coffee. Read More
  60. Willoughby Quick View

    Jasper Hill

    This succulent and buttery washed-rind cheese has aromas of peat, roasted beef and onions – a strong and complex front for the subtle milky, herbal, ripe-peach flavors within. Willoughby has a thin, tender, rosy-orange rind, which adds earthy dimension to the texture and flavors of the gooey interior. Pair with juicy rose, funky saison beer or raw floral honey. Read More
  61. Perail Quick View

    Fromagerie Papillon

    We’ve got butterflies just thinking about these creamy little rounds from Fromagerie Papillon, France’s renowned producer of Roquefort. Traditionally made when the herd wasn’t producing large enough quantities of milk for Roquefort, the soft-ripened wheels are crafted from pasteurized ewe’s milk in the rocky hillsides of Causses. Similar to Brebirousse d’Argental, or an unwashed Reblochon, the sheep’s rich milk imparts a sweet, sheepy character to the buttery-smooth paste that makes an unparalleled pair with bubbly wines. Read More
  62. Miranda Quick View

    Vulto Creamery

    A tribute like no other, this Absinthe-washed masterpiece is named for cheese-maker Jos Vulto’s late wife who wished to have a cheese named after her. Made with raw cow’s milk at his creamery in the Catskills and washed in a locally produced Absinthe called Meadow of Love, the light orange rind imparts bright herbaceouness to the lightly bubbled, savory interior. The cheese’s meaty paste complements a pairing of smoky speck and tangy pickles. Read More
  63. Blue Earth Quick View

    Alemar Cheese Company
    Blue Earth

    Financial-service-man-turned-cheese-maker, Keith Adams, named his cheese company by combining his two daughters, Alex and Mari and began making fine, heartland cheeses back in 2009. Blue Earth is the latest addition to his growing line of grass-fed, pasteurized cow’s milk cheeses. It’s an all-American brie-style round with grassy, buttery flavors that permeate from snowy rind to oozing cream line and down through its rich, fudgy center. Read More
  64. Good Thunder Quick View

    Alemar Cheese Company
    Good Thunder

    Keith Adams, once a finance guy, turned cheesemaker back in 2009 when he transformed his first vat of locally sourced milk into cheese. Based on Old World standards, Pont l’Eveque and Reblochon, Good Thunder is an orange, wrinkly-rind square of dense cream line and creamy paste that spreads wonderfully over torn pieces of fresh bread and sturdy crackers. It’s washed with a local Minnesota craft beer, Surly Bender, and picks up funk and smoothness as it ages. And it goes great with malty ales and well-seasoned salami. Read More
  65. Bleu de Berger Quick View

    Fromagerie Mont Royal Tradition
    Bleu de Berger

    600 feet above sea level, at the base of “Napoleon’s Nose” in Basque country, you’ll find Fromagerie Mont Royal Tradition where this firm raw sheep’s milk tomme is made. The recipe started off as an attempt to replicate Roquefort, but resulted in a much milder paste with smooth, fruity notes, not without some distinct sheepiness. Its closest relative is Ossau Iraty Vielle, another of the region’s traditional natural rind, sheep tommes. The cheese’s fruity aspects are fittingly paired with Black Cherry Confit and some of the region’s fruitier rosés. Read More
  66. Cave Aged Murray's CaveMaster Hollander Quick View

    Murray's CaveMaster Hollander

    Murray’s first European Cavemaster Reserve in almost 10 years, this sheepy stunner comes to us “green” from the Pyrenees, and spends two months growing a beautiful mold-mottled rind in our caves. The toothsome paste is redolent of sweet cashews, with a firmly acidic backbone, a perfect pair with a lively Jurançon. Read More
  67. Petit Billy Quick View

    Petit Billy

    Oh Billy your chevre is so light and fresh perfect for a picnic date with a bottle of grassy white. A rindless straight-up version from our Loire Valley producer of Selles sur Cher. Read More
  68. French Double Cream Brie Quick View

    French Double Cream Brie

    This butter bomb is your excuse to go nuts—the pleasantly mild, exceptionally creamy wedge is just begging for your creative touch. Read More
  69. Mimolette Quick View


    This cratered, dusty cannonball is like Edam, but much more French; the look and aroma of the rind comes from tiny cheese mites, munching away at the deeply caramel, electric-orange paste during at least 22 months of aging. Neat! Read More
  70. Cave Aged Rupert Quick View

    Consider Bardwell Farm

    Vermont ain't the Alps, but their Alpines ain't shabby. Try Rupert-a golden-yellow wheel with deep, round flavor followed by a hint o'butterscotch.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  71. Reading Quick View

    Spring Brook

    Based on the Alpine cheese Raclette, this American farmhouse version is a little salty/funky, with a zippy finish. Classicly melted on potatoes. Why mess with a classic? Read More
  72. Roth GranQueso Quick View

    Roth Kase
    Roth GranQueso

    This is a New World spin on Manchego, classic of the Old World. Same nutty, rich profile and sweet, mellow finish - but made with cow's milk from Wisconsin's dairymen.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  73. Red Wax Gouda Quick View

    Maple Leaf
    Red Wax Gouda

    An old fashioned farmer co-op and a cheesemaker with 40 years of experience in Wisconsin makes this old favorite a hit again, with its extra creaminess and touch of tang. Cheese for the masses indeed. Read More
  74. Appenzeller Käserei Tufertsch Quick View

    Appenzeller Käserei Tufertsch

    We’ve fallen head over wheels for this absolutely superlative Alpine treasure. Redolent of toasted hazelnuts and baked custard, with flavors of caramelized shallots and savory herbs, this is hands-down the best Appenzeller we’ve ever tasted. Read More
  75. Pata de Cabra Quick View

    Pata de Cabra

    Pungent, tangy, aromatic and shaped like the leg of the animal whose milk it is made with. Yum! A washed-rind variety made in very small quantities. When young, it is fruity and refined with a robust ''kick'' at the finish. With a little extra age, it becomes more pungent and powerful. Read More
  76. Cashel Blue Quick View

    Cashel Blue

    300 years ago, the Grubbs were exiled from England for religious differences. England made a big mistake, because 280 years later, the Grubbs developed this sublime Irish Blue (the first ever!), boasting a creamy texture and a minerally tang. Made from pasteurized Friesian cow's milk. Read More
  77. Cave Aged Pyrenees Brebis Quick View

    Pyrenees Brebis

    The first cheese we called ''compulsively edible,'' and still the best. Once you pop, you can't stop. Read More
  78. Out of stock Roomano Quick View


    Looking like orange granite - and just as difficult to neatly slice, this is Murray's most aged selection (3-4 years). It's a Dutch cheese that's similar to Gouda with a sweet-salty butterscotch character. Crunchy! Read More
  79. Dunbarton Blue Quick View

    Roelli Cheese Haus
    Dunbarton Blue

    Fourth generation cheesemaker Chris Roelli committed the equivalent of blue cheese heresy by piercing his cheese and then pressing it to inhibit the mold growth. The result is Dunbarton Blue, a sort of blue-veined cheddar that's potent yet approachable. In a typical blue, the pierce holes introduce air that allows the desirable mold to proliferate within the cheese. By pressing it, Chris halts the process, developing a distinct but subtle bluing that hints at piquancy without punching you in the face. A unique and fantastic cheese from a true American cheesemaking family. Read More
  80. Burrata Quick View


    Burrata - Sweet fresh cream and 'stracciatella,' or ribbons of tender curd, encapsulated within a delicate membrane of milky mozzarella. See also: the most indulgent fresh cheese in the world.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  81. Gjetost Quick View


    Pronounced “Yay-toast” (think: Yay! I’m putting this on my toast!), we’re fond of slicing ribbons onto wedges of crisp, green apples and washing it down with a nutty brown ale and, naturally, hard cider. Read More
  82. Bread Cheese Quick View

    Bread Cheese

    In Finland they call it ‘Juustoleipa’, which roughly translates to what we call it around these parts. Make no mistake; there isn’t any bread involved. It's all pasteurized cows milk that's baked just after formation into cheese, hence the roasty toasty appearance. Read More
  83. Gorgonzola Cremificato Quick View

    Gorgonzola Cremificato

    Morning milk makes melting blues. Heavy cream and Italian cultures also have something to do with the thick creaminess of the 'sweet' gorgonzola. Serve with honeyed pears for dessert- and never look back... Read More
  84. Monte Enebro Quick View

    Monte Enebro

    An exuberant goat cheese in three acts: the spicy peppery rind (thanks to a dusting of ash and blue mold) gives way to a tart and runny creamline, leading finally to a dense and lactic core. As sophisticated as it is delicious. Read More
  85. Brillat Savarin Quick View

    Brillat Savarin

    Named for the greatest gastronome ever means putting your cheese where your mouth is. We do. Aged in our caves to ensure texture like buttercream icing. You like that, don't you? Read More
  86. Grayson Quick View

    Meadow Creek

    Only a family named Feete could make a big, bold, stinky cheese this astoundingly intense and delicious. And, it's seasonal. Get it while you can. Read More
  87. Black River Blue Quick View

    North Hendren Cheese Cooperative
    Black River Blue

    A classic American blue from the North Hendren Cheese Cooperative which has been making cheese for 80 years. The recipe for this blue is well-guarded, and for good reason! The texture is slightly softer than butter- a nice creamy backdrop for the bright blue flavor. Read More
  88. Roquefort Quick View

    Papillon Black Label

    The French have named this assertive, spicy sheep their 'King of Blues' and showed their loyalty by crowning it with the first AOC designation in 1925. They have since embraced democracy, but 'President of Blue' doesn't have the same ring. Read More
  89. Cave Aged Little Big Apple Quick View

    Murrays Cavemaster Reserve
    Little Big Apple

    Our cavemaster starts with fluffy white rounds of buttery Organic Champlain Valley Triple Cream that have been aged to creamy perfection in our caves. Meanwhile, handpicked apple leaves from the orchards at Warwick Winery and Distillery are soaked in Apple Jack, a brandy from Black Dirt Distilling. Then bloomy each round is hand-wrapped and tied in place with a piece of twine. We age the cheese a few days more to let the brandy work its magic, resulting in a chic little package that’s full of BIG charisma and flavor. Read More
  90. Up in Smoke Quick View

    River's Edge Chevre
    Up in Smoke

    Every time we carefully pull back the edges of the maple leaves that so delicately contain the bright, woodsy cheese bundles from Oregon’s Rivers Edge Chevre, we feel like we’re unwrapping a gift from the tree nymphs themselves. Read More
  91. Solo di Bruna Parmigiano-Reggiano Quick View

    Solo di Bruna Parmigiano-Reggiano

    Made from the milk of only Italian Brown cows, we've never tried parm like this. Buttery and caramelly, like grown-up Cracker Jacks-with that hopelessly addictive crunch as your prize inside. Curl atop your pasta or just lob off a hunk, and foist a glass of Barolo to new levels of delicious. Salute! Read More
  92. Valdeon Quick View


    This intense blue is made with a seasonal mixture of cow and goat's milk, then wrapped in either oak or sycamore leaves. A triumphant choice if you love dense blue veining and a perfect balance of salt and spice. Read More
  93. Boerenkaas Gouda Quick View

    Boerenkaas Gouda

    We call it the PB & J effect - Sweet and salty, crunchy and creamy: there's harmony in contrast. Plus, this authentic gouda is great with beer - snack time for grown-ups! Read More
  94. Aged Goat Gouda Quick View

    Aged Goat Gouda

    Looking like caramel and tasting like the crunchy top of a creme brulee if goat cream were underneath. Tell your friends you've brought 'goat cheese' to the party and delight in their wild confusion. Read More
  95. Cave Aged Bayley Hazen Blue Quick View

    Cellars at Jasper Hill
    Bayley Hazen Blue

    The Northeast Kingdom of Vermont: rumored to have more cows than people. Taste their bounty in this blue: dry, complex, and nutty, with a hint of licorice. Read More
  96. Cremeux de Bourgogne Quick View

    Cremeux de Bourgogne

    Theres just too much heavenly triple-creme to contain within one fluffy white rind. The sweetest, creamiest cat in the case we dare you not to swoon. Read More
  97. Tuxford  & Tebbutt Stilton Quick View

    Tuxford & Tebbutt Stilton

    Tuxford & Tebbutt Creamery produces this traditional earthy, minerally, pasteurized cow milk blue in the birthplace of Stilton, Melton Mowbray, England. One of only a few dairies certified to make this PDO protected cheese; it is traditionally paired with Tawny Port. Read More
  98. Goat Feta Quick View

    Goat Feta

    Mellow out why don’t-cha? We’re all for great sheep-y feta with its kicking hooves, but sometimes we go all-goat for a kinder, gentler flavor. Known for their award-winning chevres, Vermont Creamery applies traditional Greek feta-making methods into practice using 100% farm-fresh goats’ milk that results in soft, citrusy cheese. Read More
  99. Real Greek Feta Quick View

    Real Greek Feta

    We at Murray’s are particularly fond of the mighty yet humble feta. You know what it is, but have you really tasted it? Our mission is to bring you the golden ideal in all things cheese, so we recently took a trip to Greece with the specific purpose of finding a feta that would please the gods, and you. Read More
  100. Queso Invierno Quick View

    Queso Invierno

    Cows and sheep work together to get the job done in this mixed milk cheese from Vermont. A little nutty, a little flakey, but firm enough to stand up to the competition. Read More
  101. Cave Aged Selles-sur-Cher Quick View


    The little black dress of goat cheese, aged in our very own caves for a thin rind, oozy creamline and exquisite texture. Perfect fit, everytime. Read More
  102. Cato Corner Hooligan Quick View

    Cato Corner Farm
    Cato Corner Hooligan

    Our Cavemaster has reported numerous instances of Cato Corner Hooligan roughhousing Raclette and getting fresh with Fontina, but it’s a risk we’re willing to accept from this pungent, beefy tomme... Read More
  103. Cave Aged Grana Padano Quick View

    Grana Padano

    Rough handling makes tasty Italian cheese: from two milkings comes raw cow milk that is partially skimmed, cooked twice, and bathed in brine before aging for at least a year. All that attention makes a fragrant, sweet, and nutty cheese with a very firm texture. It's not Parmigiano - similar, but not exactly the same - but like its cousin, you can use it for grating, cooking, and as a fine table cheese. Read More
  104. SarVecchio Quick View


    Sartori SarVecchio wraps a feel good story about the American Worker in its nutty, caramelly parmesan-esque flavor- a combination that keeps us coming back for more. After a notable cheese giant decided to close the Antigo, Wisconsin plant that produced its most flavorful (perhaps ONLY flavorful) cheese, workers pooled their resources, bought the plant, and showed the big guy that Americans could handle cheese with incredible flavor that didn’t come in a can. Read More
  105. 2 Sisters Isabella Gouda Quick View

    2 Sisters Isabella Gouda

    This year-old gouda has it all: the dense creamy paste of a younger cheese, and the developed beefy-butterscotchy flavor and light crunch of something much older. Leaves little to be desired, save your favorite beverage pairing. Read More
  106. Creme Fraiche - 3 Pack Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Creme Fraiche - 3 Pack

    Made using traditional methods learned while working on farms in France, VBC's Allison Hooper brought her skills back to the US and crafted this exquisitely rich, creamy treat. Read More
  107. Tilsiter Quick View


    A hold-over from the Prussian Empire, Tilsiter is a pungent, versatile table cheese now produced across northern Europe. This funky, raw milk production is still best eaten the Prussian way – often, and with the darkest beer and bread around. Read More
  108. La Tur Quick View

    La Tur

    When is a cheese like a scoop of delicious savory ice cream? When it's made from sheep, goat and cow's milk and gently ripened so that its melty rind oozes over a dense and creamy interior. Make mine a double! Read More
  109. Mozzarella di Bufala Quick View

    Mozzarella di Bufala

    If fresh mozzarella is the cheese you can’t wait to take home to Mom, Mozzarella di Bufala is the one you’ll feel compelled to marry on the spot. Carefully crafted from the milk of water buffalo-- the richest milk in the cheesemaking arsenal, with more than twice as much butterfat as cow’s milk-- buffalo mozzarella is a gorgeous contradiction: at once feather-light and unmistakably rich, delicate and assertively full flavored, buttery, grassy and tangy all at once. Read More
  110. Asiago Pressato Quick View

    Asiago Pressato

    Sweet, soft, young, and slightly acidic. My teenage years? No, an Italian pasteurized cow milk cheese aged for less than a month. D.O. protected. Read More
  111. Prairie Breeze Cheddar Quick View

    Prairie Breeze Cheddar

    This award-winning cheddar produced by the Musser family uses milk from local Amish farms, all within 15-miles of the creamery. Sweet and balanced, it's medium sharp and has the nuttiness of an alpine cheese with subtle grassy tones. Read More
  112. Truffle Tremor Quick View

    Cypress Grove
    Truffle Tremor

    Truffles, yes. Gimmicky, never. America's most famous goaty cake of a cheese flecked with fungal goodness. Just say yes. Read More
  113. Harbison Quick View

    Cellars at Jasper Hill

    The baby of the Jasper Hill family, born from the marriage between Winnemere and Moses Sleeper. A cradle of spruce bark imparts a pine-y flavor to the oozy, floral paste. Read More
  114. Cabra Romero Quick View

    Cabra Romero

    What happens when you take a young and springy Spanish goat cheese and add a thick layer of Rosemary to the rind? You end up with the herbaceous treat that is Cabra Romero! Read More
  115. Leonora Quick View


    Refined, uncomplicated, and classic-the goat cheese to bring home to mother. Read More
  116. Cambozola Black Label Quick View

    Cambozola Black Label

    If you like your blues as creamy as can be, look no further. That knobby grey rind adds another layer of complexity to the triple-cream wonderland underneath. Evenly distributed blue veining means pleasant, but not overwhelming, blue flavor. Read More
  117. Cave Aged Bandaged Cheddar Quick View

    Bleu Mont Dairy
    Bandaged Cheddar

    The bandages heal any trace of “boring” in this Wisconsin cheddar. We age each highly variable wheel of pasteurized cow’s milk to a balanced sweet-in-the-middle, mossy-at-the-rind. Doppel beers match well this cheese’s lingering acidity. Read More
  118. Sale Cave Aged Chevrot Quick View


    Regular Price: $18.99/EA

    Special Price: $15.99/EA

    Chevrot, you’re such a brain. Covered in a delicately wrinkled rind, we cave-age Chevrot to the top of its class, sporting a dense, lemony center, surrounded by a mushroomy, piquant creamline full of earthy intensity. Read More
  119. Green Hill Quick View

    Sweet Grass Dairy
    Green Hill

    Looking for something that's both creamy and unusual? Find it in this handmade beauty, created with milk and cream of a grass-grazing herd in Georgia. You'll also discover an amplified buttery flavor, thin rind over a silky texture, and inner peace. Read More
  120. Pecorino Foglie De Noce Quick View

    Pecorino Foglie De Noce

    Our story begins in a walnut grove set against the late spring sky of Emilia-Romagna with the tender leaves of sprawling hardwoods. Late in the season, before the leaves become bitter and dry, they are quickly gathered and layered in cozy clay crocks with just-made wheels of pecorino. Read More
  121. Cave Aged Ossau Iraty Vieille Quick View

    Ossau Iraty Vieille

    Said to be one of the first cheeses ever produced, this gem from Aquitaine, France has only gotten better with age. The wheels here at Murray’s are rumored to descend from those produced by Aristee, Apollo’s sheepherding son. Read More
  122. Fresh Mozzarella Quick View

    Lioni Latticini
    Fresh Mozzarella

    The Lioni family has been perfecting their whole cow's milk mozz for generations - it's delicate and moist with a clean milky flavor. Made nearby in New Jersey of fresh, pasteurized milk from a herd in upstate NY. Read More
  123. Pawlet Quick View

    Consider Bardwell Farm

    Pawlet’s a town that brings Americans slate, syrup and timber and-- even better-- Pawlet’s a cheese that’s delivers just as eclectic and delightful a mix. Hailing from Consider Bardwell, a farm that straddles Vermont’s picturesque Champlain Valley and New York’s agri-centric Washington County, Pawlet tastes of grassy barnyard, cultured butter, and fresh-from-the-oven 7-grain bread loaves. Read More
  124. Smokey Blue Quick View

    Rogue Creamery
    Smokey Blue

    Its true! This special version of Oregon Blue Vein is cold smoked for 16 hours over Northwest -grown hazelnut shells. The result is a balance of sweet caramel and hazelnut flavors that contrasts deliciously with the sharp bite of the blue veining. Read More
  125. Chiriboga Blue Quick View

    Chiriboga Blue

    Ecuadorian man falls in love with Bavarian woman. Cheesemaking ensues—not the typical ending to a fairytale, but a pretty delicious one, resulting in a cheese that resembles rich, cultured butter more than a peppery, assertive blue. Read More
  126. Rogue River Blue Quick View

    Rogue Creamery
    Rogue River Blue

    This amped-up classic blue is made exclusively from pastured, summer milk and wrapped in pear brandy-soaked grape leaves from the neighboring vineyard. Voluptuously dense, fruity and smoky. How terroir can you get? Read More
  127. Brunet Quick View


    Brunet is a regular birthday party. Cakey at its core with an ice cream-smooth creamline and a rind that‘s just icing on the cake. Read More
  128. Cave Aged Haystack Peak Quick View

    Haystack Mountain
    Haystack Peak

    The most delicious foothill we’ve seen, tucked beneath the shadows of the Rockies in Longmont, Colorado, Haystack Peak bursts with aromas of wet stone and flavors of sautéed mushrooms and cultured butter. Read More
  129. Cave Aged Champlain Valley Triple Cream Quick View

    Champlain Valley Creamery
    Champlain Valley Triple Cream

    Carleton Yoder makes this lovely little triple creme by hand from a neighbor's organic milk. The fluffy, buttery wonder is luxurious, satisfying and cheaper than a trip to the spa. Read More
  130. Cave Aged Caerphilly Quick View

    Westcombe Dairy

    Caerphilly, carefully. Known primarily as the grub of Welsh coalminers, this cheese has also long been made in England’s West Country by the Ducketts of Somerset, whose own production of this noble wheel began three generations ago with the raw milk from their herd of Friesian cows. Read More
  131. Tumbleweed Quick View

    5 Spoke Creamery

    If farmhouse Cheddar and French Cantal took a roll in the weeds you'd get this little square. Read More
  132. Smoked Gouda Quick View

    Maple Leaf
    Smoked Gouda

    Perfecting the craft since 1912, Maple Leaf, the Wisconsin farmer cooperative makes a creamy Gouda with real smoky flavor from Hickory. Read More
  133. Fiore Sardo Quick View

    Fiore Sardo

    Firm texture, wet smoke, and a piquant, nutty finish are hallmarks of artisan Fiore Sardo. Made of raw sheep milk, and gamey, slammin' perfection with a glass of Montepulciano. Read More
  134. Cheese Curds Quick View

    Cheese Curds

    Price From:
    Displaced Wisconsinites and snack lovers across the nation have cause to rejoice: fresh from the vat cheddar cheese curds! Read More
  135. Cave Aged Torus Quick View


    Looks like a donut, tastes like a cheesy croissant—buttered paste, yeasty rind, and a hint of minerality from its time in our caves. Read More
  136. Cave Aged Valencay Quick View


    Behold: The Pyramid of Cheese. Murray's Cave Aged means we grow the rind here so the cheese is dense and complex, the rind thin and tasty. Read More
  137. Fontina Val d'Aosta Quick View

    Fontina Val d'Aosta

    Respect the Matterhorm. Each mountainous wheel is grassy, slightly truffly, and subtly fruity. Regular washing in our caves preserves and develops complex flavor. Read More
  138. Provolone Buonatavola Quick View

    Provolone Buonatavola

    Much more sharp and full of flavor than your average deli provolone, this Italian offering adds a satisfying kick to any selection of antipasti, or well-constructed sandwich. Read More
  139. Toma Walser Quick View

    Toma Walser

    NEW ARRIVAL! The Walsers were a Germanic people that wound up settling throughout the Alps, including the Piedmont region of northern Italy. This sweet smelling, ivory-colored gem is named for them. Read More
  140. Cabot Clothbound Cheddar Quick View

    Cabot Creamery
    Cabot Clothbound Cheddar

    This ain't your supermarket Cabot. We travel to the Cellars at Jasper Hill yearly to find the perfect cheese--caramelly sweet and a little crunchy. Read More
  141. Out of stock Beaufort d'Ete AOC Quick View

    Beaufort d'Ete AOC

    French gastronome Brillat Savarin calls it "The Prince of Gruyeres." We call it the King. 'Nuff said. Read More
  142. Bonne Bouche Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Bonne Bouche

    A good mouthful, indeed! Bonne Bouche is the flagship of Vermont Creamery's signature aged goat cheeses. Read More
  143. Cave Aged Hudson Valley Camembert Quick View

    Old Chatham Sheepherding Company
    Hudson Valley Camembert

    Square Camembert? Sheep Camembert? American Camembert?!? Oh yes, the upstate flock behind this dense and creamy tile bucks convention with delicious results. Toast them with California Sparkling.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  144. Herb Goat Log Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Herb Goat Log

    A 25 year history and a slow, authentic process make this chevre stand out. First, milk is collected from small, local farms in Vermont. Fermentation is allowed to last a full 24 hours to make it incredibly creamy and another day's draining sets it to perfection.

    Read More

  145. Gorgonzola Mountain Quick View

    Gorgonzola Mountain

    Here it is! The spicy, dense and milky blue you require for that. . . cheese plate / salad / burger / cream sauce / pastry filling / wing dip / Sangiovese pairing. Circle one. This classic Gorgonzola is a natural choice. Read More
  146. Young Manchego Quick View

    Young Manchego

    Young and spry Manchego- better for melting at three months than its aged counterpart, and more fun at parties; just add membrillo, marcona almonds, and a cask of Rioja. Read More
  147. Shropshire Blue Quick View

    Shropshire Blue

    It looks like Stilton that fell into a vat of sunshine. This creamy, robust blue is made from pasteurized cow's milk in Nottinghamshire, England. A relatively recent addition to the Cheese Pantheon, it was invented by Mrs. Hutchison Smith in the 1970s. Read More
  148. Parmigiano Reggiano Bonati Quick View

    Parmigiano Reggiano Bonati

    Father and son cheesemakers Georgio and Gianluca Bonati are the overachievers of Parmigiano Reggiano production, going above and beyond in every aspect of craft to ensure a final wheel of impeccable quality, redolent of fresh walnuts, cooked milk, and spring grass. Read More
  149. Murray's Burrata Quick View

    Murray's Burrata

    We’re not just buttering you up: imagine a fresh white ball of mozzarella, filled with thick, luscious cream. That’s our Burrata. Read More
  150. Dorset Quick View

    Consider Bardwell Farm

    Plump as a Dorset milkmaid, but New England style: toothsome, pungent and easy to enjoy, ideally with porter. Read More
  151. Cave Aged Sainte-Maure de Touraine Quick View

    Sainte-Maure de Touraine

    Oh lovely lemony log, how I delight in your goaty goodness. How I exalt your herbal essence. How I adore your careful Murrays-aging of 2-4 weeks. Read More
  152. Fourme d'Ambert Quick View

    Fourme d'Ambert

    This cheese is in rare Fourme. Time in our caves yields a sweet, super-creamy bite that will convert even the staunchest blue cheese hater. Read More
  153. Cave Aged Colston Bassett Stilton Quick View

    Colston Bassett Stilton

    This farmstead Stilton is rumored to be the best in the world. Creamy, buttery, earthy with a clean, mineral tang on the finish. Break out the pears, walnuts, and Port. Read More
  154. Salva Cremasco Quick View

    Salva Cremasco

    A cheese cube that doesn't come in your grocer's fridge section. A natural, earthy rind gives it that herbaceous kick, and we age it to develop the milky undertones. Read More
  155. Manchester Quick View

    Consider Bardwell Farm

    This is one feisty goat! Brine washing in our caves imparts a pungent kick to its paste, and the flavor swells to a peppery bite on the finish.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  156. Middlebury Blue Quick View

    Middlebury Blue

    This zippy blue greets you with a firm handshake, but its Vermont farmstead roots are revealed in down-to-earth grassy flavors and a mellow finish. Read More
  157. Cave Aged Epoisses Quick View


    One slurp of the intensely creamy paste of this French classic, and you’ll know why we go to such lengths to ensure that this unctuous pasteurized cow’s milk round, made in Burgundy, France, is so delightfully decadent. Tucked into a clever wooden box meant to ease transport to our fair shores, serving Époisses isn’t nearly as difficult as aging it—slice a crusty baguette and dunk away, adding a glass of Burgundian white for terroir-driven perfection. Read More
  158. Halloumi Quick View


    The grilling cheese, from Cyprus - made from pasteurized sheep and goat milk with a smattering of mint. Skewer cubes on kabobs or pan-sear for breakfast with eggy toast this springy, mildly briny wonder just wont melt. Read More
  159. Coupole Quick View

    Vermont Creamery

    Perfection is this 'dome' shaped, hand-ladled treat from Websterville, Vermont. Bright, fresh chevre gets sweet and creamy just beneath the velvety, edible rind.Plus it reminds us of Honeydew from the Muppets. 2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  160. Plain Goat Log - 10 ounce Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Plain Goat Log - 10 ounce

    Fresh and lemony. Perfect for your favorite recipe. Ours: stuffed into tangy peppadew. A real treat! First, milk is collected from small, local farms in Vermont. Fermentation is allowed to last a full 24 hours to make it incredibly creamy and another day's draining sets it to perfection Read More
  161. Taleggio Quick View


    This iconic Italian washed-rind has been made in northern Italy since the 9th century. Pungent, fruity and meaty - ripe wheels should eat like pudding- delicious, stinky pudding that goes with wine. Try Barbera or Soave. Read More
  162. Piave Vecchio Quick View

    Piave Vecchio

    Ever wish you could eat a pound of Parm, but find the hard, dry texture a challenge? Piave is the easy eatin' version, packing all that savory crystalline nuttiness within a smooth, sliceable paste. Grab a salami and you're all set. Read More
  163. Sottocenere Quick View


    A heady mix of flavors in this unusual, semi-soft cheese from the Veneto in Italy: truffles in the pasteurized cow milk paste; ground nutmeg, coriander, cinnamon, licorice, cloves, and fennel on the ashed rind. (Hint: ''sotto cenere'' means ''under ash.'') Read More
  164. Brebirousse D'Argental Quick View

    Brebirousse D'Argental

    An ooey-gooey wonder sure to please any crowd, with a creamy paste that threatens to run free of its annatto-tinged rind. Luscious and silky enough for brie-lovers, sheepy and full-flavored enough for the most adventurous palate, its bright orange rind refuses to be ignored, but its delicate sweetness balances the buttery intensity with aplomb. Read More
  165. Murray's Summer Reserve Comte Quick View

    Murray's Summer Reserve Comte

    Hand-selected by our Alp-scaling buyers, this Summer Reserve batch is a rare member of the Comte one percent deemed worthy of extra aging for deepened, more complex flavor. Eat it now: exclusivity guaranteed; endless wheels are not. Read More
  166. Capra Sarda Quick View

    Capra Sarda

    The Brothers Pinna create these sweet, toothsome wheels to honor the outnumbered goats on an island famous for having more sheep than people. Ideal for grating, but compulsively edible with a mainland favorite, the bright white, Gavi di Gavi. Read More
  167. Quadrello di Bufala Quick View

    Quadrello di Bufala

    Something old-7th century Italian cheese. Something new-Quadrello, not mozzarella. Something borrowed-Taleggio recipe. Somethingbuffalo? Creamy-sweet paste with washed rind funk. Read More
  168. Caciocavallo Quick View


    Caciocavallo earns its name, literally ‘cheese on horseback’, from the way duos of gourd-shaped rounds are rope-bound and slung over a wooden board to drain and age. Read More
  169. Fulvi® Pecorino Romano Quick View

    Fulvi® Pecorino Romano

    Part of the daily rations for Roman Legionaries in the 1st century AD. Fulvi® is still traditionally made from pasteurized sheep's milk in the Roman countryside and is less hard and dry than its Sardinian-made counterparts. No need to ration, we have enough for you. Read More
  170. Tomme de Savoie Quick View

    Tomme de Savoie

    An Alpine cheeseboard staple, traditionally made with the partially skimmed milk left over from butter-making. Youve probably come looking for this earthy, vegetal, straightforward classic, so no cheeky puns will be necessary here. Read More
  171. Cave Aged Crottin de Chavignol Quick View

    Crottin de Chavignol

    Dropped in our caves as a quiet, unassuming fresh chevre, crafted from pasteurized goat’s milk, Crottin de Chavignol emerges from its lair a changed being... Read More
  172. Klaverkaas Estate Gouda Quick View

    Klaverkaas Estate Gouda

    An authentic farmers cheese made in the Netherlands for generations, this is Gouda as intended: fresh, buttery cow’s milk with a savory, nutty bite. The name Klaverkaas, or ‘clover cheese’, refers to a diet rich in green clover that the pampered Holstein-Friesian herd enjoys day in and day out. Read More
  173. Delice des Cremiers with Truffles Quick View

    Delice des Cremiers with Truffles

    Unbelievably luscious triple-crème studded with ultra-decadent black truffles. Makes every day a celebration! Read More
  174. Cave Aged Cavemaster Reserve Barden Blue Quick View

    Cavemaster Reserve Barden Blue

    A slice of Barden Blue is everything we imagine a perfect day at Vermont’s picturesque Consider Bardwell Farm to be: mellow, grassy, and pleasantly full, with a sunshiney brightness. The newest cheese in Consider Bardwell’s line-up, Barden Blue’s buttery flavor and bright, golden hue can be traced to the best raw, local cow’s milk delivered each morning straight to the cheesemaking room. Read More
  175. Drunken Goat Quick View

    Drunken Goat

    Soon after it's made, this goat's milk cheese from Murcia, Spain is dunked in a barrel of Paso Doble red wine for a full 48 hours. The rind turns an appetizing shade of purple, while the interior remains a bright shade of white and gains a mild fruity flavor. Read More
  176. Tete de Moine Quick View

    Tete de Moine

    If you have a Girolle, you too can shave ''the monk's head.'' A strong raw cow's milk cheese from the Jura Mountains, assertively fruity and full-bodied. Read More
  177. Fromage Blanc - 3 Pack Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Fromage Blanc - 3 Pack

    Let that yogurt take a morning off, and give this a try. Read More
  178. Mascarpone - 3 Pack Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Mascarpone - 3 Pack

    How sweet it is. This velvety rich Italian answer to cream cheese is a total cheese-bomb. Read More
  179. New York State Cheddar Quick View

    Great lakes
    New York State Cheddar

    It’s no secret- New Yorkers love cheese. Heck, we’ve even got a museum dedicated entirely to the cheese of New York State - and this hunk of sharp, grassy goodness, full of the same spunk and sass that defines a native New Yorker, serves as an edible monument to the centuries-long history of Empire State cheese. Read More
  180. Gruyere Quick View


    It’s been around since the 13th century—one taste and you’ll join its ranks of admirers. While traditional Gruyere may age anywhere from six months to three years, Murray’s carefully selects special wheels with incredible aging potential that we finish in our own caves for a full twelve-month maturation. Read More
  181. Mahon Curado Quick View

    Mahon Curado

    Four to six months of aging in salty and dry conditions on the Spanish island of Minorca result in a unique and powerful cheese: bright, flakey, salty and with the unmistakable tang of vinegar. Read More
  182. Preferes des Montagnes Quick View

    Preferes des Montagnes

    As close to the illicit French Reblochon as you're going to get. Innocuous, buttery goodness with just a hint of pungency. Made of cow's milk in Savoie like the real thing, but pasteurized with a generic name - Sneaky! Read More
  183. Ardrahan Quick View


    Blimy! This Cork County curd combines clovered fields of Ireland's coast with briny saltwater below. We wash each wheel to encourage oceanic undertones. Read More
  184. Fromager d'Affinois Quick View

    Fromager d'Affinois

    Extra creamy cousin of Brie, this French innovation is buttery, sweet, and mild. Rich and pleasant, and especially lovely with fresh fruit and champagne. Read More
  185. Morbier Quick View


    Mobier? Try More Bien! The ash once separated morning and evening milkings, but now it's a decorative cue to a washed rind that we finish to pungent and peanutty perfection. Read More
  186. Sale Plain Goat Log Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Plain Goat Log

    Regular Price: $4.99/EA

    Special Price: $3.99/EA

    A 25 year history and a slow, authentic process make this chevre stand out. First, milk is collected from small, local farms in Vermont. Fermentation is allowed to last a full 24 hours to make it incredibly creamy and another day's draining sets it to perfection. Read More
  187. Cremont Quick View

    Vermont Creamery

    The delicate, crinkly rind on this American Original encases a deceptively rich and tasty cheese, thanks to the addition of tart creme fraiche. It may not be socially acceptable to down in two bites, but just you try resisting its advances.
    2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  188. Langres Quick View


    Who needs a flute when your cheese can hold your bubbly for you? Made in Champagne and finished with a concave top designed to hold a bit of the eponymous sparkler, cheesemakers wash each little cow’s milk round with brine and then rub it with raccou, a natural colorant derived from a tropical shrub. Read More
  189. Delice de Bourgogne Quick View

    Delice de Bourgogne

    Want to make sure that all the sweet, decadent triple creme is gone by the time the party's over? This tidy little format should do the trick. Otherwise, get two and hide one in the crisper for personal use. Read More
  190. Oma Quick View


    The von Trapp family farm in Waitsfield, VT has expanded and improved with every generation, most recently with brothers Dan and Sebastian who started making cheese. Their newly tweaked Oma recipe makes an approachably pungent washed rind, rich but well-balanced, with hints of roasted peanuts. Read More
  191. Marieke Aged Gouda Quick View

    Marieke Aged Gouda

    Believe it not, this cheese is all American--though we never would have guessed that it didn't come from the Netherlands. Read More
  192. Fontina Fontal Quick View

    Fontina Fontal

    Young, mild cheese seeks sandwich, pizza, or nourishing snack with anyone up for a good time. A little dense - but flexible, sweet and easygoing. Will stop the world to melt with you. Read More
  193. Cave Aged Montgomery's Cheddar Quick View

    Montgomery's Cheddar

    The. Definitive. English. Clothbound. Cheddar. Known to taste like the fatty, crunchy edge of a well-cooked roast beef. You deserve it. Read More
  194. Landaff Quick View

    Landaff Creamery

    Inspiration, found Caer-fully. An American original which, like its Welsh counterpart, is exceptionally easy to eat enormous quantities of, whilst drinking beer. Read More
  195. Challerhocker Quick View


    NEW! Translating to ''sitting in the cellar'', Challerhocker is washed in wine and spices and then aged for a minimum of 10 months, providing a remarkable depth of flavor. Read More
  196. Etivaz Quick View


    37 Alps, 37 producers, 1 seasonal, traditional cheese made over open fires. Love Gruyere? Prepare for your next obsession. Read More
  197. Blu di Bufala Quick View

    Blu di Bufala

    Say ''Yes!'' to decadence. A high fat (like half-and-half) and high style (cube-shaped) water buffalo blue. Yup, they make those. Read More
  198. Cave Aged Tarentaise Quick View

    Spring Brook Farms

    A do-gooder in inspiration: Abondance. A do-gooder in society: produced on a farm that gives city kids a rural experience. A do-gooder in taste: spicy with a pineapply finish that's perfect with Gamay Beaujolais.
    2014American Cheese Society Winner! Read More
  199. Queso Idiazabal Quick View

    Queso Idiazabal

    I love your animal nature, you gamy raw sheep milk cheese. Traditionally made in the Basque country, young wheels were hung in fireplaces to pick up a little smokiness. Read More
  200. Cave Aged Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged Quick View

    Uplands Cheese Company
    Pleasant Ridge Reserve Extra Aged

    A firm raw cow milk cheese with intense fruit and olive flavors.
    2014 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  201. Cave Aged Berkswell Quick View


    Sure is swell. Balanced, sweet, and deliciously nutty with a long finish, this seasonal darling is made by the Fletcher familys Ram Hall Dairy. Read More
  202. Podda Classico Quick View

    Podda Classico

    Zing! Get electrified by the zippy finish of this sweet, nutty pasteurized cow and sheep milk cheese from the island of Sardinia. A hint of lemony spice makes it even more irresistible. Read More
  203. Westfield Farm Capri Quick View

    Westfield Farm
    Westfield Farm Capri

    The freshest of the fresh, made weekly only a few hours away by Westfield Farms. Clean, lactic and creamy, this whole-milk goat cheese is naturally the lightest in the case. Lean, mean, and local? Sold! Read More
  204. Garrotxa Quick View


    This moist and cakey aged goat cheese sports a suede jacket of grey mold. Belying these rugged looks are lingering flavors of white pepper and damp wood, thanks to cave-aged origins. Read More
  205. Le Chevre Noir Quick View

    Le Chevre Noir

    We love this fromage. Pale and smooth with a bit of a crunch, this gently pasteurized goat milk cheddar will wow you with its fruity sharpness. Fabrique au Quebec, baby. Read More
  206. Pecorino Ginepro Quick View

    Pecorino Ginepro

    Bathed in a solution of balsamic vinegar and juniper berries, this raw sheep's milk cheese is then attentively aged at least four months. The flakey paste and perfectly edible rind balance hints of gin and acidity with the natural richness of sheep's milk. Read More
  207. Comte Saint Antoine Quick View

    Comte Saint Antoine

    This Saint is sent from on high. Murray's selects the fruitiere and age profile for a reliable flavor balance between mellow fruity notes and cooked cream. Read More
  208. Malvarosa Quick View


    This farmhouse cheese from Valencia, Spain is one of the most ''snackable'' I've had in quite some time, and part of my job is to eat cheese all day, so that's saying something. Buttery, rich, and sweet, with a compliant texture. Made with pasteurized Guirra sheep milk. Read More
  209. Zimbro Quick View


    Meet our buddy Zimbro. Bound with strips of white cloth to contain the thick, pudding-like interior with its delicate, slightly sour flavor. Read More
  210. Cave Aged Hudson Flower Quick View

    Murrays Cavemaster Reserve
    Hudson Flower

    Our riff on Corsican classic, Fleur du Maquis. Young wheels of decadent sheep's milk cheese from nearby Old Chatham get a fresh fall coat... Read More
  211. Bleu d'Auvergne Quick View

    Bleu d'Auvergne

    A medium-strength, versatile blue we think of as Roquefort's nemesis. Made in a similar style, but with raw cow's milk, the sliceable paste is mellow and meaty with the perfect balance of salt and spice. Read More
  212. Mrs. Quicke's Cheddar Quick View

    Quickes Traditional
    Mrs. Quicke's Cheddar

    Smoother, moister, and milder than its counterparts, Mrs. Quicke's is the model of cheddared, ladylike delicacy. Murray's select wheel sfor lemony, citrus notes. Perfect with crisp fall apples. When she's on, she sparkles. Read More
  213. Moses Sleeper Quick View

    Cellars at Jasper Hill
    Moses Sleeper

    Ayrshire cow's milk is formed into discs a bit larger than your typical Camembert, then aged with care in the Cellars at Jasper Hill for the next six weeks. Once released, Moses usually has a classic white bloomy rind, with a smattering of exotic mauve- and dandelion-hued molds heightening its complexity. Read More
  214. Casatica di Bufala Quick View

    Casatica di Bufala

    Unbelievably rich and sweet milk makes for a zaftig, custardy little beauty, barely restrained by its bloomy rind. Get out of my dreams and onto my cheese board. Read More
  215. Vacherin Mont D'Or Quick View

    Vacherin Mont D'Or

    Perhaps one of the most sought-after cheeses on the market. A thermalized cow's milk cheese with a round of spruce to contain the woodsy liquid interior that, with one taste, commands spontaneous exuberance. Read More
  216. Robiola Bosina Quick View

    Robiola Bosina

    This luscious little slab of mild, creamy goodness is made from a blend of milks for the perfect balance of salty and milky sweet. Its tender rind is good eats - resist that uncivilized urge to bite it like a pastry. Read More
  217. French Raclette Quick View

    French Raclette

    Raclette, from the French verb meaning ''to scrape.'' Sscrape up every bit of this salty, leaty bad boy once melted atop potatoes. Read More
  218. Young Goat Gouda Quick View

    Young Goat Gouda

    Fool your non-goat-cheese-loving friends with this mild sweetie that reveals minimal goatiness. Palate-pleasing texture, pretty pale paste. Made in Holland, of pasteurized goat's milk. Read More
  219. Smoked Mozzarella Quick View

    Lioni Latticini
    Smoked Mozzarella

    After generations, the Lioni family has perfected the moist and delicate curd of their pasteurized cows milk mozzarella. They take it a step further here with a heady treatment of hickory and cherry wood-smoke. Read More
  220. Roncal Quick View


    Looking for an excellent Spanish sheep's milk cheese? This D.O.-protected raw milk goodie from the Basque region is full-bodied, gamy, and just a little bit musty. Read More
  221. Kunik Quick View

    Nettle Meadow

    A powerful one-two punch. Begin with tangy goat milk and enrich with Jersey cow cream for buttery decadence. Then, ripen in Murray's cave for a mineral finish and perfect rind. Read More
  222. Mitibleu Quick View


    Monsieur Roquefort bought a villa in La Mancha and goes by the name of Seor Mitibleu. The firm, moist paste has a sheepy aroma, which accompanies a sharp kick from the blue-green veining and an eye-watering tangy mineral finish. Vino de Jerez anyone? Read More
  223. Tickler English Cheddar Quick View

    Tickler English Cheddar

    We're not quite sure what a French tickler is, but we're positive about the English one - it's a mature, robust cheddar - aged 18 months to sweet, tangy perfection. Made from raw cow's milk in Devon. Read More
  224. Caveman Blue Quick View

    Caveman Blue

    Introduced in 2009, this one just might be the best of the Rogue creamery bunch. Thankfully, its mellow spice probably won't club you over the head and drag you back to the cave. Read More
  225. Camembert Quick View


    Temptation lives in a round, wooden box. This petit fromage is deliciously nutty and dewy when ripe, with the aroma of wet rope. A fully ripe specimen displays a melting straw-colored paste with assertive mushroom flavors. Read More
  226. Bucheron Quick View


    And you thought goat cheese was only the fresh white stuff. Check the two-textured magic that a round slice of b-log has to offer; rich and creamy, a bit fresh and citrusy- a little something for everyone. Read More
  227. Humboldt Fog Quick View

    Cypress Grove
    Humboldt Fog

    You may be expecting a cheesecake, but it's really one of the most famous American chevres. Mary Keehn from Humboldt County, CA, makes this tangy treat with a beautiful bloomy rind and a line of vegetable ash bisecting each wheel. 2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More
  228. Irish Cheddar Quick View

    Irish Cheddar

    Firm, mild pasteurized cows' milk cheddar. Superb for grating and melting. Read More
  229. Pecorino Oro Antico Quick View

    Pecorino Oro Antico

    With even a remedial knowledge of Italian, you've probably figured out on your own that this means ''Old Gold Sheep Cheese.'' Yup, it's pasteurized, aged for 6 months, and ''Gold'' refers not only to its color, but to its excellence. Firm and flaky, it has the beloved aged sheep cheese flavors: sheepy, nutty, and grassy. Precious. Read More
  230. Brie Fermier Quick View

    Brie Fermier

    Made at the ''Farm of rejuvenation'' in Northern France, this brie is the best we've found yet. Mushroomy and fungal, gooey and creamy, you'll get hints of fresh shucked oysters and a tiny bit of iron.We think we're in love. Read More
  231. Cave Aged Emmenthaler Swiss Quick View

    Emmenthaler Swiss

    My, what big eyes you have. That's what the holes in real Swiss mountain cheese are called. And this is as real as it comes. Get melting. Read More
  232. Haxaire Munster Quick View

    Haxaire Munster

    While true Alsatian Munster isn't street legal in the US on account of it being raw and under 60 days, this pasteurized version does a pretty mean impression. Read More

Grid View List View