Visitor Monitoring
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.

Cave Aged

Grid View List View

28-36 of 41

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  1. Cave Aged Kinderhook Creek Quick View

    Old Chatham Sheepherding Company
    Kinderhook Creek

    Kinderhook Creek is the newest darling from New York's Old Chatham Sheepherding Company. Made from 100% pure East Friesian sheep's milk, we mature this cheese to tangy, mushroomy perfection in the caves below our shop. Read More
  2. Cave Aged Cornelia Quick View

    Cave Master Reserve

    An homage to the original location of Murray’s, Cornelia arrives just-formed from Point Reyes Farmstead. Pampered first in our sauna-like washed rind cave, then finished in our natural rind cave, she develops a sublimely buttery, rich paste with a roasted peanut finish. Cornelia is perfect on her own, but she totally digs the company of a medium-bodied red and bold charcuterie. Read More
  3. Cave Aged The Other Stephen Quick View

    The Other Stephen

    We love St. Stephen. These heavenly little discs are 75% butterfat, with a decadent flavor profile that hits on notes of fresh cream and butter-soaked mushrooms. But this particular St. Stephen is no Saint – this one comes bathed in Short, Dark & Handsome, an American stout from Other Half Brewing in Brooklyn. At 7.00% ABV, the beer wash brings some rowdiness to the cheese, imparting notes of roasted coffee beans, dark cocoa, hops and flowers, with a nice salty finish that might just get you a little rowdy yourself. Read More
  4. Middlebury Blue Quick View

    Middlebury Blue

    This zippy blue greets you with a firm handshake, but its Vermont farmstead roots are revealed in down-to-earth grassy flavors and a mellow finish. Read More
  5. Cave Aged Hudson Flower Quick View

    Murrays Cavemaster Reserve
    Hudson Flower

    Our riff on Corsican classic, Fleur du Maquis. Young wheels of decadent sheep's milk cheese from nearby Old Chatham get a fresh fall coat... Read More
  6. Salva Cremasco Quick View

    Salva Cremasco

    A cheese cube that doesn't come in your grocer's fridge section. A natural, earthy rind gives it that herbaceous kick, and we age it to develop the milky undertones. Read More
  7. Cave Aged Bayley Hazen Blue Quick View

    Cellars at Jasper Hill
    Bayley Hazen Blue

    The Northeast Kingdom of Vermont: rumored to have more cows than people. Taste their bounty in this blue: dry, complex, and nutty, with a hint of licorice. Read More
  8. Cave Aged Colston Bassett Stilton Quick View

    Colston Bassett Stilton

    This farmstead Stilton is rumored to be the best in the world. Creamy, buttery, earthy with a clean, mineral tang on the finish. Break out the pears, walnuts, and Port. Read More
  9. Cave Aged Berkswell Quick View


    Sure is swell. Balanced, sweet, and deliciously nutty with a long finish, this seasonal darling is made by the Fletcher familys Ram Hall Dairy. Read More

Grid View List View

28-36 of 41

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5