Cheddar
-
Cave Aged
Quick View
Isle of Mull Cheddar
$29.99/LBThis cheddar is full of Scottish spirit. The cows are fed mash from a local whiskey distillery, resulting in a cheese that is yeasty and sharp with a boozy prickle. Perfect with single-malt. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Duckett's Caerphilly
$29.99/LBCaerphilly, carefully. Known primarily as the grub of Welsh coalminers, this cheese has also long been made in England’s West Country by the Ducketts of Somerset, whose own production of this noble wheel began three generations ago with the raw milk from their herd of Friesian cows. Read More -
Quick View
Bandaged Cheddar
$36.99/LBThe bandages heal any trace of “boring” in this Wisconsin cheddar. We age each highly variable wheel of pasteurized cow’s milk to a balanced sweet-in-the-middle, mossy-at-the-rind. Doppel beers match well this cheese’s lingering acidity. Read More -
Quick View
Lincolnshire Poacher
$34.99/LBThe paste is dense and firm, with a flavor and smell somewhere between cheddar and Gruyère. Aged for nearly two years, this cheese develops a mellow nutty quality, and visible crystals that add that addictive little crunch on the palate. Read More -
Quick View
Ellsworth Creamery
Cheese CurdsPrice From:$5.99/EADisplaced Wisconsinites and snack lovers across the nation have cause to rejoice: fresh from the vat cheddar cheese curds! Read More -
New
Quick View
Cabot Creamery
Murray's Select Vermont Cheddar$12.99/LBFrom Vermont’s cheddar experts at Cabot, a classic cheddar, just for Murray's. It’s a nutty classic that fits the grill—get it now at this sweet introductory price and it fits the bill, too! Read More -
Quick View
2 Sisters Isabella Gouda
$17.99/LBThis year-old gouda has it all: the dense creamy paste of a younger cheese, and the developed beefy-butterscotchy flavor and light crunch of something much older. Leaves little to be desired, save your favorite beverage pairing. Read More
Shop By
Country
- USA (8)
- The Netherlands (1)
- United Kingdom and Ireland (7)
Price
- $0.00 - $20.00 (7)
- $20.00 - $40.00 (9)
Tell us what you like!
- Bold (1)
- Buttery (2)
- Caramelly (3)
- Comforting (3)
- Crowd-Pleasing (4)
- Crumbly (5)
- Earthy (3)
- From Our Caves (3)
- Fudgy (1)
- Funky (1)
- Good for Kids (6)
- Grassy (4)
- Hard (2)
- Lingering (3)
- Meaty (2)
- Mellow (2)
- Rustic (2)
- Salty (1)
- Savory (2)
- Sharp (4)
- Sweet (3)
- Tangy (3)
- Traditional (3)
- With a story (2)
Rennet Type
Pairings
- Scotch (5)
- Bourbon (2)
- Lagers and Kolsch (3)
- Hoppy Beers (8)
- Farmhouse Ales (3)
- Belgian-Style Ales (2)
- Porters and Stouts (1)
- Cabernet Sauvignon (2)
- Pinot Noir (1)
- Malbec (5)
- Merlot (4)
- Syrah and Shiraz (2)
- Chardonnay (12)
- Sparkling Wine (1)
- Cider (8)
