Visitor Monitoring
Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheddar

Cheddar

Grid View List View

  1. Cave Aged Cabot Clothbound Cheddar Quick View

    Cabot Creamery
    Cabot Clothbound Cheddar

    $24.99/LB
    This ain't your supermarket Cabot. We travel to the Cellars at Jasper Hill yearly to find the perfect cheese--caramelly sweet and a little crunchy. Read More
  2. Sale Flory's Truckle Quick View

    Milton Creamery
    Flory's Truckle

    Regular Price: $30.99/LB

    Special Price: $22.99/LB

    Milton Creamery worked hand-in-hand with the Flory Family of Jamesport, Missouri to develop this aged clothbound cheddar. It has a peppery aroma, a dry crumbly texture and a rich grassy flavor. Read More
  3. Cave Aged Mrs. Quicke's Cheddar Quick View

    Quickes Traditional
    Mrs. Quicke's Cheddar

    $26.99/LB
    Smoother, moister, and milder than its counterparts, Mrs. Quicke's is the model of cheddared, ladylike delicacy. Murray's select wheel sfor lemony, citrus notes. Perfect with crisp fall apples. When she's on, she sparkles. Read More
  4. Tumbleweed Quick View

    5 Spoke Creamery
    Tumbleweed

    $24.99/LB
    If farmhouse Cheddar and French Cantal took a roll in the weeds you'd get this little square. Read More
  5. Landaff Quick View

    Landaff Creamery
    Landaff

    $28.99/LB
    Inspiration, found Caer-fully. An American original which, like its Welsh counterpart, is exceptionally easy to eat enormous quantities of, whilst drinking beer. Read More
  6. Cave Aged Montgomery's Cheddar Quick View

    Montgomery's Cheddar

    $34.99/LB
    The. Definitive. English. Clothbound. Cheddar. Known to taste like the fatty, crunchy edge of a well-cooked roast beef. You deserve it. Read More
  7. Le Chevre Noir Quick View

    Le Chevre Noir

    $35.99/LB
    We love this fromage. Pale and smooth with a bit of a crunch, this gently pasteurized goat milk cheddar will wow you with its fruity sharpness. Fabrique au Quebec, baby. Read More
  8. Cave Aged Caerphilly Quick View

    Westcombe Dairy
    Caerphilly

    $33.99/LB
    Caerphilly, carefully. Known primarily as the grub of Welsh coalminers, this cheese has also long been made in England’s West Country by the Ducketts of Somerset, whose own production of this noble wheel began three generations ago with the raw milk from their herd of Friesian cows. Read More
  9. Cave Aged Bandaged Cheddar Quick View

    Bleu Mont Dairy
    Bandaged Cheddar

    $36.99/LB
    The bandages heal any trace of “boring” in this Wisconsin cheddar. We age each highly variable wheel of pasteurized cow’s milk to a balanced sweet-in-the-middle, mossy-at-the-rind. Doppel beers match well this cheese’s lingering acidity. Read More

Grid View List View