Visitor Monitoring
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Butter & Dairy

Grid View List View

  1. Cultured Butter Basket, 2 Pack Quick View

    Vermont Creamery
    Cultured Butter Basket, 2 Pack

    $9.99/EA
    It's the 14 carat diamond of butters - freshly churned creaminess bedazzled with Celtic sea salt. Read More
  2. White Moustache Yogurt Quick View

    White Moustache Yogurt

    $7.99/EA

    When we say we LOVE this crazy-hard-to-find yogurt, we really mean it. Made in super small batches from an old world Persian recipe with no preservatives, this yogurt is crafted entirely by hand. Fruit preserves are spooned into the jars one by one. Every jar contains an almost unfathomable amount of time and labor, the dedication of a very small company with very big ideas about flavor. We buy this yogurt for ourselves all the time and now we’re glad to share it with you. Our very highest recommendation.

    Signature Flavors

    Greek: Traditional, clean, perfect Kiss: Greek with orange blossom honey and walnuts Yalda: Greek with raisins, mint and walnuts Sour Cherry: Super fruity and tart Date: Man oh man, arguably our favorite!

    Please note that White Moustache is a specialty item that is not always available for immediate shipping. We recommend placing your order a several days in advance. If White Moustache is included as part of a larger order, please understand that these jars may be shipped separately.

    Read More
  3. Murray's Mascarpone Quick View

    Murray's Mascarpone

    $6.99/EA
    Creamier than butter. Silkier than ricotta. Richer than your favorite triple crème. A tub of magic. This fresh Italian treat is a dessert superstar, perfect for stuffing cannoli and making tiramisu. Drizzle with honey and serve with whatever fresh fruits make you happy. Mascarpone also shines in savory dishes: plop into pasta, mashed potatoes or tomato soup for no-joke lavishness. 8.8 oz. Read More
  4. Old Chatham Yogurt Quick View

    Old Chatham Yogurt

    $3.99/EA
    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  5. Ben's Cream Cheese Quick View

    Ben's Cream Cheese

    $7.99/EA
    Lauded in the New York Times, The New Yorker and Gourmet Magazine, this Lower East Side Dairy tradition redefines - or better yet, is the original definition of - cream cheese. Sweet with a hint of tang, what really sets Ben's apart is its consistency: clean, thick, creamy, and dense, devoid of gums and stabilizers, not grainy, not gummy. Rich in texture and in history, this pure product puts the Philly stuff in the tinfoil envelope to shame. Read More
  6. Salted Butter Log - 2 Pack Quick View

    Salted Butter Log - 2 Pack

    $9.99/EA
    To paraphrase Julia Child, a little butter makes life a lot better. Read More
  7. Unsalted Butter Log - 2 Pack Quick View

    Unsalted Butter Log - 2 Pack

    $9.99/EA
    To paraphrase Julia Child, a little butter makes life a lot better. Read More
  8. Old Chatham Large Yogurt (16 ounces) Quick View

    Old Chatham Large Yogurt (16 ounces)

    $5.99/EA
    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More

Grid View List View