Eat Cheese, Give Back | From now until May 30, a percentage of our sales will go to Send Chinatown Love. | Shop for a Good Cause
Cart(0)

Your Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty
  • 888-692-4339
  • Store Locations
  • Sign up for CheezE-Mail
  • Login
  • Register
What's Hot
  • What's New
  • Deals
  • Build Your Own Gift
  • Gift Guide
  • Shop Cheese
      • Shop Cheese
        • Murray's Cheeses
        • Alpine
        • Blue
        • Brie & Creamy
        • Buffalo's Milk Cheese
        • Cheddar
        • Cow's Milk Cheese
        • Firm
        • Fontina & Melting
        • Fresh & Chevre
        • French Cheeses
        • Goat's Milk Cheese
        • Gouda
        • Grating Cheeses
        • Grilling Cheeses
        • Gruyere
        • Hard
        • Italian Cheeses
        • Manchego and Sheepy
        • Mixed Milk Cheese
        • Mozzarella
        • Parmigiano & Pecorino
        • Semi-Firm
        • Sheep's Milk Cheese
        • Shredded & Grated
        • Smoked & Flavored
        • Soft
        • Stinky
        • Swiss & Nutty
        • Truffle Cheese
        • Washed Rind
        • Butter & Dairy
        • What's New in Cheese
      • Features
        • Sale
        • Father's Day
        • Seasonal Cheeses
        • Best Sellers
        • Grilling
        • Truffle Cheeses
        • Murray's Cave Aged
        • Buy More Save Big
        • Classic Cheese of the Month Club
        • Cheesemonger's Picks of the Month Club
      • Makers
        • Murray's Cheeses
        • Murray's Cheese Caves
        • Made in USA
        • Wisconsin Cheese
        • Vermont Cheese
        • Point Reyes
        • Vermont Creamery
        • von Trapp Farmstead
        • Rogue Creamery
        • Grafton Village Cheese
        • Jasper Hill
        • Shop by Maker

      Dig in to our favorite seasonal cheeses, like bright and tangy Herb Garlic Capri.

      Shop Spring
  • Shop Meats
      • Shop Meats
        • Murray's Charcuterie
        • Bacon
        • Cooked & Cured
        • Pâté, Mousse & Spreads
        • Prosciutto
        • Salami
        • Sausages & Hot Dogs
        • Sliced Meats
        • Tinned Fish
      • Features
        • Sale
        • Father's Day
        • Grilling
        • Meat Collections & Pairings
        • Perfect Pair of the Month Club
        • What's New in Meats
      • Makers
        • Murray's Charcuterie
        • Olympia Provisions
        • Brooklyn Cured
        • Carnegie Deli
        • Seemore Meats & Veggies
        • Trufflin
        • Fabrique Delices
        • Charlito's Cocina
        • Matiz España
        • Creminelli
        • Shop by Maker

      Seemore’s creative veg-forward sausages will be the star of your next barbecue.

      Shop Seemore
  • Shop Pantry
      • Shop Pantry
        • Murray's Provisions
        • Honey
        • Jams & Spreads
        • Crackers
        • Baked Goods
        • Nuts & Dried Fruit
        • Olives & Antipasti
        • Pickles
        • Tinned Fish
        • Condiments & Sauces
        • Oil & Vinegar
        • Chocolates & Sweets
        • Pasta & Rice
        • Butter & Dairy
        • Vegan
      • Features
        • Sale
        • Father's Day
        • Grilling
        • Truffle Gifts
        • Mac & Cheese Favorites
        • Recipe Favorites
        • Buy More Save Big Sale
        • What's New in Pantry
      • Makers
        • Murray's Provisions
        • Rustic Bakery
        • Callie's Biscuits
        • Carnegie Deli
        • Trufflin
        • Murray's Olive Oils
        • Murray's Vinegars
        • Rustichella D’Abruzzo
        • Z Crackers
        • Shop by Maker

      Add some fun to your pantry with Ramp Up’s bright and briny Ramp Vinegar.

      Shop Vinegar
  • Shop Gifts
      • Shop Gifts
        • Murray's Collections
        • Monthly Clubs
        • Business Gifts
        • Gift Cards
        • Gifts Under $50
        • Gifts Under $100
        • Gifts Under $200
        • Murray's Apparel
        • Murray's Accessories
        • Cheese Towers
        • Cyber Monday
        • Black Friday
      • Build Your Own Gift
        • Build Your Own Gift
      • Features
        • Father's Day
        • Truffle Gifts
        • Luxury Gifts
        • Gifts for Host & Hostess
        • Hosting Favorites
        • Seasonal Favorites
        • Made in New York
        • Classes
        • Private Classes
        • Boot Camp
      • Housewares
        • Cheese Boards
        • Cheese Knives
        • Serveware
        • Graters & Tools
        • Cheese Bags & Storage
        • Cheese Serveware Gifts
        • Murray's Accessories

      Our Top Shelf Collection is peak cheese decadence, perfect for presents and for parties.

      Give A Gift
  • Monthly Clubs
      • Monthly Clubs
        • Classic Cheese of the Month
        • Cheesemonger's Picks of the Month
        • Perfect Pair of the Month
        • Cheese Board of the Month
        • Mac and Cheese of the Month
        • View All
      • Features
        • Boards, Knives & Tools
        • Pairing Guide
        • Monthly Club FAQ

      Build your own expert-level spread with our Cheese Board of the Month club.

      Sign Up Now
  • Recipes, Ideas & Cheese Boards
      • Recipes
        • Great Taste by Murray's
        • Happy Hour by Murray's
      • Cheese Boards
        • Cheese Boards by Murray's
        • How to Cut & Serve Cheese
        • Boards & Knives
        • Graters & Tools
      • Inspiration
        • Cheese Caves by Murray's
        • Murray's Blog
        • Behind the Rind
        • Beverage Pairing Guide
        • Cheese in the Community
      • What's Hot
        • Made in New York
        • Shop by Country
        • Shop by Maker
        • Cheese Vocabulary

      Baked Cheesy Brussels Sprouts Dip is a warm, gooey app that’ll please any cheese lover.

      Get The Recipe
  • Catering, Events & Classes
      • Education
        • Classes
        • Murray's Boot Camp
        • Private Classes
        • FAQs
      • Catering
        • Catering
        • Menu
        • Murray's Cheese Towers
      • Events
        • Private Events
        • The Leroy Room

      Join us for classes online! We’ll ship you four cheese pairings, and you can follow our experts through a virtual tasting.

      Join Us Now
  • More Murray's
      • Our Businesses
        • Wholesale
        • Retail
        • Online
        • Catering
        • Events & Education
        • The Leroy Room
        • Cheese Bar
        • Cheese Caves
        • Corporate Gifts
        • Concierge Gifting
        • View All
      • Meet Me at Murray's
        • Our Blog
        • In the News
        • In the Community
        • In the Caves
      • More Murray's
        • About Us
        • CheezE-Mail
        • Murray's Cave Aged
        • Promotions
        • Branded by Murray's
        • Shop All Branded by Murray's

      Contact our Wholesale Team today for information on ordering for restaurant menus, hotels, and more.

      Our Offerings
  • Home
  • Cheese
  • Cheddar Cheese
Back

Your Refinements

  • Pasteurization: "Pasteurized"
Clear All

Cave Type

  • Cavemaster Reserve

Country

  • Canada
  • United States
  • Ireland
  • England

Milk Type

  • Cow
  • Goat

Price

$21.00$5.00

Pasteurization

  • Pasteurized
  • Raw
  • Thermalized

Pairings

  • Bourbon
  • Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Chardonnay
  • Cider
  • Farmhouse Ales & Sours
  • Lagers and Kolsch
  • Malbec
  • Merlot
  • Pale Ales & IPAs
  • Pinot Noir
  • Porters and Stouts
  • Sauvignon Blanc
  • Scotch Whiskey

Rennet Type

  • Animal
  • Vegetarian
  • Microbial

Cheddar Cheese, Pasteurized

Showing 1-14 of 14  

List viewGrid view
sort by:
per pageshow:
Narrowed By: Pasteurized
Clear All
Beehive Cheese Red Butte Hatch Chile
$30.00/Lb
Murray's Cave Aged Original Stockinghall Cheddar
$30.00/Lb
Cellars At Jasper Hill Cabot Clothbound Cheddar
$34.00/Lb
Mystic Cheese Co. Cachalot
$36.00/Lb
Goat Cheddar
$24.00/Lb
Murray's Irish Cheddar
$18.00/Lb
Murray's Aged English Cheddar
$17.00/Lb
Murray's High Plains Cheddar
$25.00/Lb
New York State White Cheddar 6 months
$10.00/Lb
New York State Yellow Cheddar 6 months
$10.00/Lb
Quicke's Mature Cheddar
$35.00/Lb
Bleu Mont Dairy Bandaged Cheddar
$42.00/Lb
Tickler Cheddar
$24.00/Lb
Ellsworth Creamery Cheddar Cheese Curds 16 oz
$12.00/Each
  • 1 of 1
Back to Top

Sign up for CheezE-mail

Save 10% on your first order by signing up for our newsletter!

Subscribe

Thanks for signing up! Stay tuned for some cheesy emails.

About Murray's

  • About Murray's
  • Locations
  • Cheese Caves
  • In the Community
  • In the News
  • Careers at Murray's
  • Our Blog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Do Not Sell My Info

Looking For Help

  • Customer Service
  • How we ship
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Pairing Guide
  • Give 10%, Get 10%
  • Affiliate Program
  • Employee Portal

Our Businesses

  • Greenwich Village
  • Grand Central Market
  • Long Island City
  • Catering
  • Wholesale
  • Murray's Cheese Bar
  • The Leroy Room
  • Mac & Cheese
  • See All

Call Us

  • 888-My Cheez
  • (888-692-4339)
  • Customer Service Hours
  • Mon - Fri 9am - 6pm ET
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Blog
  • Instagram
COPYRIGHT ©2022 MURRAY'S CHEESE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.