Visitor Monitoring
Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheese

Cheese

Grid View List View

1-9 of 17

  1. 1
  2. 2
  1. Jalapeno Jack Quick View

    Jalapeno Jack

    $13.99/EA
    This Jack is packing heat— fresh red and green Jalapeños add a kick to buttery cheese made with milk from a 16-farm cooperative in Wisconsin. Bursting with south-of-the-border flavor, eat immediately or melt over nachos or burgers. Read More
  2. Beecher's Flagship Cheddar Quick View

    Beecher's Flagship Cheddar

    $29.99/LB
    Carefully aged for 15 months to fully develop its complex flavor and ever-so-slight crumble. Read More
  3. Cave Aged Vermont Shepherd Quick View

    Vermont Shepherd

    $35.99/LB
    We're fans of authenticity, but this is one knock-off we love. Made from raw sheep's milk in Putney, VT, this round was the result of Cynthia and David Major's months of cheesemaking training in the French Pyrenees. Read More
  4. Cave Aged Grayson Quick View

    Meadow Creek
    Grayson

    $28.99/LB
    Only a family named Feete could make a big, bold, stinky cheese this astoundingly intense and delicious. And, it's seasonal. Get it while you can. Read More
  5. Black River Blue Quick View

    North Hendren Cheese Cooperative
    Black River Blue

    $9.99/LB
    A classic American blue from the North Hendren Cheese Cooperative which has been making cheese for 80 years. The recipe for this blue is well-guarded, and for good reason! The texture is slightly softer than butter- a nice creamy backdrop for the bright blue flavor. Read More
  6. Queso Invierno Quick View

    Queso Invierno

    $31.99/LB
    Cows and sheep work together to get the job done in this mixed milk cheese from Vermont. A little nutty, a little flakey, but firm enough to stand up to the competition. Read More
  7. SarVecchio Quick View

    Sartori
    SarVecchio

    $21.99/LB
    Sartori SarVecchio wraps a feel good story about the American Worker in its nutty, caramelly parmesan-esque flavor- a combination that keeps us coming back for more. After a notable cheese giant decided to close the Antigo, Wisconsin plant that produced its most flavorful (perhaps ONLY flavorful) cheese, workers pooled their resources, bought the plant, and showed the big guy that Americans could handle cheese with incredible flavor that didn’t come in a can. Read More
  8. Green Hill Quick View

    Sweet Grass Dairy
    Green Hill

    $14.99/EA
    Looking for something that's both creamy and unusual? Find it in this handmade beauty, created with milk and cream of a grass-grazing herd in Georgia. You'll also discover an amplified buttery flavor, thin rind over a silky texture, and inner peace. Read More
  9. Cave Aged Champlain Valley Triple Cream Quick View

    Champlain Valley Creamery
    Champlain Valley Triple Cream

    $8.99/EA
    Carleton Yoder makes this lovely little triple creme by hand from a neighbor's organic milk. The fluffy, buttery wonder is luxurious, satisfying and cheaper than a trip to the spa. Read More

Grid View List View

1-9 of 17

  1. 1
  2. 2