Visitor Monitoring
Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheese

Cheese

Grid View List View

  1. Cave Aged Valentine Quick View

    Ancient Heritage Farm
    Valentine

    $14.99/EA
    It's a party! Valentine looks like a wee pillar of cloud and tastes like a sheep's milk cheesecake - the luscious, airy interior easily gives way between your teeth as waves of herbaceous, grassy flavor wash over your senses. What better way to celebrate spring than a little bit of cake? Read More
  2. Cave Aged Vermont Shepherd Quick View

    Vermont Shepherd

    $39.99/LB
    We're fans of authenticity, but this is one knock-off we love. Made from raw sheep's milk in Putney, VT, this round was the result of Cynthia and David Major's months of cheesemaking training in the French Pyrenees. Read More
  3. Cave Aged Kinderhook Creek Quick View

    Old Chatham Sheepherding Company
    Kinderhook Creek

    $24.99/EA
    Kinderhook Creek is the newest darling from New York's Old Chatham Sheepherding Company. Made from 100% pure East Friesian sheep's milk, we mature this cheese to tangy, mushroomy perfection in the caves below our shop. Read More
  4. Murray's Cavemaster Reserve Fromage à Trois Quick View

    Murray's Cavemaster Reserve Fromage à Trois

    $45.99/EA
    Our collaboration with Old Chatham Sheepherding Company in upstate New York brings you 3 special cheeses—only available RIGHT HERE. This fine trio is perfect for an at-home tasting party. Read More
  5. Cave Aged San Andreas Quick View

    Bellwether Farms
    San Andreas

    $32.99/LB
    This nicely balanced raw farmstead sheep tomme is made in California, near the fault line for which it is named. Nutty with subtle hints of buttercups and moss. Read More
  6. Cave Aged Condor's Ruin Quick View

    Condor's Ruin

    $17.99/EA
    Our friends at Many Fold Farm make a variety of seasonal, farmstead cheeses from the ewes’ milk produced on their farm. Named for the ruins of an old dairy, Condor’s Ruin is only made during the milking season (and that’s right now!). Read More
  7. Ewe Bloom Quick View

    Prairie Fruits Farm
    Ewe Bloom

    $15.99/EA
    Prairie Fruits Ewe Bloom is made from milk collected the same day on a neighboring Mennonite farm. Reminiscent of the French cheese Perail, its straw-colored paste sports perfect breakdown and delicate sheep flavor. Read More
  8. Cave Aged Hudson Flower Quick View

    Murrays Cavemaster Reserve
    Hudson Flower

    $34.99/EA
    Our riff on Corsican classic, Fleur du Maquis. Young wheels of decadent sheep's milk cheese from nearby Old Chatham get a fresh fall coat... Read More
  9. Cave Aged C-Local Quick View

    C-Local

    $29.99/EA
    Murray's cave manager Brian Ralph first hatched the idea for C-Local cheese on his commute to work, on - you guessed it - the C train. Read More

Grid View List View