Cheese
-
Quick View
Uplands Cheese Company
Rush Creek Reserve$33.99/EAGet excited - this is the cold-weather cheese of your dreams. Resinous, bacony, and only barely restrained by a band of spruce. Seasonally produced, from only the highest-quality milk. Warm it up, if you dare. . . Read More -
Quick View
Cellars at Jasper Hill
Winnimere$39.99/EAThe Kehler Brothers put a Vermont spin on Swiss Forsterkase. Like running through an edible, savory forest, this spruce bark cinched washed-rind jumps onto your palate with delicately pungent, woodsy creaminess. Divine. Read More -
Quick View
-
Quick View
Penterman Farm
Marieke Aged Gouda$22.99/LBBelieve it not, this cheese is all American--though we never would have guessed that it didn't come from the Netherlands. Read More -
New
Quick View
Cabot Creamery
Murray's Select Vermont Cheddar$12.99/LBFrom Vermont’s cheddar experts at Cabot, a classic cheddar, just for Murray's. It’s a nutty classic that fits the grill—get it now at this sweet introductory price and it fits the bill, too! Read More -
New
Sale
Quick View
Painted Goat Fresh Chevre
Price From:Regular Price: $11.99/EA
Special Price: $9.99/EA
We age a number of our cheeses in our caves to great effect, but Painted Goat boasts the unique distinction of having cave-aged its cheesemaker-- Ilyssa Berg, who handcrafts creamy, grassy goat cheeses in upstate New York with her partner Javier Flores, learned the art of affinage beneath our Greenwich Village store. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Murray's Cavemaster Reserve
C-Local$29.99/EAMurray's cave manager Brian Ralph first hatched the idea for C-Local cheese on his commute to work, on - you guessed it - the C train. Read More -
New
Quick View
Floyd
Beer CheesePrice From:$9.99/EABeer... Cheese... Beer Cheese! Need we say more? Brooklyn-made, Kentucky-inspired spicy cheddar dips that have smooth swagger you can spread all over pretzels, crackers, fingers…whatever you can think of. Read More -
Quick View
Ellsworth Creamery
Cheese CurdsPrice From:$5.99/EADisplaced Wisconsinites and snack lovers across the nation have cause to rejoice: fresh from the vat cheddar cheese curds! Read More
Shop By
Category
- Blue (9)
- Brie & Creamy (14)
- Cheddar (8)
- Dairy (5)
- Fresh & Chevre (19)
- Fontina & Melting (1)
- Gouda (2)
- Manchego & Sheepy (3)
- One of a Kind (12)
- Parmigano & Pecorino/Grating (1)
- Swiss & Nutty (7)
- Stinky (5)
- Smoked & Flavored (4)
- Tommes (1)
- Best Sellers (7)
- Cave Aged (23)
- Sale (3)
- New (7)
- Vermont Butter and Cheese Creamery (12)
Milk Type
Price
- $0.00 - $20.00 (40)
- $20.00 - $40.00 (39)
Tell us what you like!
- Blue (6)
- Bold (3)
- Buttery (10)
- Caramelly (3)
- Challenging (4)
- Comforting (6)
- Creamy (11)
- Crowd-Pleasing (16)
- Crumbly (7)
- Decadent (6)
- Delicate (7)
- Earthy (6)
- For a special occasion (4)
- From Our Caves (13)
- Fruity (4)
- Fudgy (6)
- Funky (5)
- Good for Kids (14)
- Gooey (1)
- Grassy (9)
- Hard (3)
- Herbaceous (3)
- Lingering (7)
- Magical (6)
- Meaty (4)
- Mellow (10)
- Minerally (7)
- Modern (15)
- Mushroomy (2)
- Nutty (5)
- Romantic (6)
- Rustic (3)
- Salty (3)
- Savory (1)
- Serious (3)
- Sharp (2)
- Silky (2)
- Smoky (4)
- Soft (5)
- Spicy (1)
- Stinky (3)
- Subtle yet complex (6)
- Sweet (4)
- Tangy (7)
- Unforgettable (10)
- Vegetal (1)
- Velvety (3)
- Wacky (7)
- With a story (4)
Rennet Type
Pairings
- Merlot (12)
- Syrah and Shiraz (7)
- Chianti (2)
- Tempranillo (3)
- Chardonnay (16)
- Pinot Grigio (2)
- Riesling (12)
- Sauvignon Blanc (5)
- Chenin Blanc (4)
- Sparkling Wine (1)
- Rose (7)
- Cider (19)
- Dessert and Fortified Wines (5)
- Scotch (4)
- Bourbon (7)
- Rum (2)
- Fruit Brandies (3)
- Gin (1)
- Wheat Beers (10)
- Lagers and Kolsch (9)
- Hoppy Beers (7)
- Farmhouse Ales (9)
- Belgian-Style Ales (11)
- Porters and Stouts (6)
- Strong Beers (6)
- Cabernet Sauvignon (7)
- Pinot Noir (10)
- Malbec (4)
