Visitor Monitoring
Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheese

Cheese

Grid View List View

1-9 of 220

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  1. Ewephoria Sheep Milk Gouda Quick View

    Ewephoria Sheep Milk Gouda

    $19.99/LB
    If you're feeling vulnerable, then definitely don't have a taste of this sweet, crunchy novelty. Seriously - no one has ever said no. Read More
  2. New Arzua Ulloa Quick View

    Arzua Ulloa

    $25.99/EA
    On the banks of the Ulluo River in Galicia, where Arzua Ulloa is made and loved, it is sometimes called queixo do pays, meaning "cheese of the land". The name-protected beauty is crafted from milk from Rubia Gallega, Frisian and Alpine Brown cows that graze on the area’s green pastures. It’s aged for a mere two weeks—the pasteurized cheese is mild yet complex, redolent of freshly churned butter and proofing bread dough. Arzua Ulloa’s natural, straw yellow rind makes way to reveal a satiny ivory paste, smooth and unrelentingly creamy. Arzua Ulloa is a superstar melter. Make a no-joke grilled cheese, with or without quince paste (we vote with). Or serve with honey and marcona almonds, beside a crisp Albariño. Read More
  3. New Bauma Madurat Quick View

    Bauma Madurat

    $31.99/EA
    Toni Chueca is a pioneer. He started making gorgeous farmstead goat’s cheeses in Catalunya in 1980, in a region devoid of goat’s milk cheese. Since then, the cheese has reached the apex of its deliciousness. These days, it abounds—especially Toni’s Madurat, a friendly, pasteurized log covered in veggie ash. The cheese is dense and smooth, with bright, lemony notes and a mushroomy mellowness. It’s genius crumbled in salads and omelets, or served beside anchovies and olives for an elegant appetizer. Pop open a bottle of lively Cava, or a crisp Pale Ale. Read More
  4. New Old Chatham Yogurt Quick View

    Old Chatham Yogurt

    $3.99/EA
    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  5. New Kinderhook Creek Mini Quick View

    Kinderhook Creek Mini

    $9.99/EA
    Kinderhook Creek is a pure sheep's milk, soft-ripened cheese. This bloomy rind surrounds a wonderfully creamy, earthy center that will become oozy upon reaching its peak. This is a specialty item and will be shipped separately from your order. We generally ship these on the Tuesday after your order is place. Trust us, it’s worth the wait! Read More
  6. Jarlsberg Quick View

    Jarlsberg

    $12.99/EA
    We all know this nutty cheese with the buttery texture and large eye-holes. Jerry (of Tom and Jerry fame) would find a hiding space in this “classic” Swiss-style cheese. Great for parties or baiting traps. Read More
  7. Cave Aged Project X Quick View

    Project X

    $24.99/LB
    From the hidden laboratories deep within Murray’s Caves, our newest experiment emerges: Project X! A collaboration with Spring Brook farm in Vermont, this raw cow’s milk tomme takes its inspiration from the rugged mountain cheeses of Italy, with our own Northeast twist. We coat these wheels with a generous helping of herbaceous fennel pollen, followed by repeated bathing in Gewurztraminer from New York’s Finger Lakes. The result is incredible: lusciously moist, with flavors of roasted walnuts, cocoa and anise. Equally at home on a cheese board or melted in pasta, with a glass of Alpine-style white wine. Read More
  8. Cave Aged The Other Stephen Quick View

    The Other Stephen

    $24.99/EA
    We love St. Stephen. These heavenly little discs are 75% butterfat, with a decadent flavor profile that hits on notes of fresh cream and butter-soaked mushrooms. But this particular St. Stephen is no Saint – this one comes bathed in Tall, Dark & Handsome, an American black ale from Other Half Brewing in Brooklyn. At 7.00% ABV, the beer wash brings some rowdiness to the cheese, imparting notes of roasted coffee beans, dark cocoa, hops and flowers, with a nice salty finish that might just get you a little rowdy yourself. Read More
  9. Murray's Brie Quick View

    Murray's Brie

    $7.99/EA
    When the mushroomy, garlicky intensity of Fromage de Meaux is more than you want, pasteurized French Brie offers a creamy and mild, buttery flavor familiar to all who have purchased most other well-known brands. This one is a true double creme 60% brie, meaning it is 60% butterfat in dry matter (but 100% brie). Sturdy and economical enough for baking in pastry or slicing for artsy sammies. Light bodied, fruity whites are best for pairing. Read More

Grid View List View

1-9 of 220

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5