Cheese
-
Quick View
SarVecchio
$21.99/LBSartori SarVecchio wraps a feel good story about the American Worker in its nutty, caramelly parmesan-esque flavor- a combination that keeps us coming back for more. After a notable cheese giant decided to close the Antigo, Wisconsin plant that produced its most flavorful (perhaps ONLY flavorful) cheese, workers pooled their resources, bought the plant, and showed the big guy that Americans could handle cheese with incredible flavor that didn’t come in a can. Read More -
Quick View
2 Sisters Isabella Gouda
$17.99/LBThis year-old gouda has it all: the dense creamy paste of a younger cheese, and the developed beefy-butterscotchy flavor and light crunch of something much older. Leaves little to be desired, save your favorite beverage pairing. Read More -
Quick View
Pecorino Oro Antico
$24.99/LBWith even a remedial knowledge of Italian, you've probably figured out on your own that this means ''Old Gold Sheep Cheese.'' Yup, it's pasteurized, aged for 6 months, and ''Gold'' refers not only to its color, but to its excellence. Firm and flaky, it has the beloved aged sheep cheese flavors: sheepy, nutty, and grassy. Precious. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Montgomery's Cheddar
$29.99/LBThe. Definitive. English. Clothbound. Cheddar. Known to taste like the fatty, crunchy edge of a well-cooked roast beef. You deserve it. Read More -
Quick View
Walter Rass
Appenzeller Käserei Tufertsch$32.99/LBWe’ve fallen head over wheels for this absolutely superlative Alpine treasure. Redolent of toasted hazelnuts and baked custard, with flavors of caramelized shallots and savory herbs, this is hands-down the best Appenzeller we’ve ever tasted. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Mrs. Quicke's Cheddar
$22.99/LBSmoother, moister, and milder than its counterparts, Mrs. Quicke's is the model of cheddared, ladylike delicacy. Murray's select wheel sfor lemony, citrus notes. Perfect with crisp fall apples. When she's on, she sparkles. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Grana Padano
$19.99/LBRough handling makes tasty Italian cheese: from two milkings comes raw cow milk that is partially skimmed, cooked twice, and bathed in brine before aging for at least a year. All that attention makes a fragrant, sweet, and nutty cheese with a very firm texture. It's not Parmigiano - similar, but not exactly the same - but like its cousin, you can use it for grating, cooking, and as a fine table cheese. Read More -
Quick View
Ellsworth Creamery
Cheese CurdsPrice From:$5.99/EADisplaced Wisconsinites and snack lovers across the nation have cause to rejoice: fresh from the vat cheddar cheese curds! Read More -
Quick View
Caciotta di Capra con Pepe
$22.99/LBA goat in sheep’s clothing. This caciotta, or “little cheese,” hails from the land of sheep’s milk Pecorino but has a flavor all its own—preserved lemons, brown butter, and the spice of whole black peppercorns. Read More
Shop By
Category
- Brie & Creamy (2)
- Cheddar (9)
- Gouda (1)
- One of a Kind (3)
- Parmigano & Pecorino/Grating (6)
- Swiss & Nutty (1)
- Smoked & Flavored (1)
- Tommes (1)
- Best Sellers (5)
- Cave Aged (5)
Country
- USA (7)
- France (1)
- Italy (6)
- Canada (1)
- The Netherlands (2)
- Switzerland (1)
- Spain (1)
- United Kingdom and Ireland (2)
Milk Type
Tell us what you like!
- Bold (1)
- Buttery (1)
- Caramelly (3)
- Challenging (1)
- Comforting (2)
- Crowd-Pleasing (6)
- Crumbly (4)
- Earthy (3)
- From Our Caves (3)
- Funky (1)
- Good for Kids (4)
- Grassy (3)
- Hard (9)
- Lingering (3)
- Meaty (3)
- Mellow (2)
- Modern (1)
- Mushroomy (1)
- Nutty (2)
- Romantic (1)
- Rustic (1)
- Salty (5)
- Savory (3)
- Sharp (3)
- Smoky (1)
- Spicy (1)
- Sweet (4)
- Tangy (2)
- Traditional (4)
- Unforgettable (1)
- With a story (2)
Rennet Type
