Visitor Monitoring
Close
We’ll keep you in the loop on new cheese & deals!
And we’ll never sell or share your info.
Cart(0)
888-692-4339

Cheese

Cheese

Grid View List View

1-9 of 99

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  1. Ewephoria Sheep Milk Gouda Quick View

    Ewephoria Sheep Milk Gouda

    $19.99/LB
    If you're feeling vulnerable, then definitely don't have a taste of this sweet, crunchy novelty. Seriously - no one has ever said no. Read More
  2. New Old Chatham Yogurt Quick View

    Old Chatham Yogurt

    $3.99/EA
    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More
  3. New Kinderhook Creek Mini Quick View

    Kinderhook Creek Mini

    $9.99/EA
    Kinderhook Creek is a pure sheep's milk, soft-ripened cheese. This bloomy rind surrounds a wonderfully creamy, earthy center that will become oozy upon reaching its peak. This is a specialty item and will be shipped separately from your order. We generally ship these on the Tuesday after your order is place. Trust us, it’s worth the wait! Read More
  4. Jarlsberg Quick View

    Jarlsberg

    $12.99/EA
    We all know this nutty cheese with the buttery texture and large eye-holes. Jerry (of Tom and Jerry fame) would find a hiding space in this “classic” Swiss-style cheese. Great for parties or baiting traps. Read More
  5. Murray's Brie Quick View

    Murray's Brie

    $7.99/EA
    When the mushroomy, garlicky intensity of Fromage de Meaux is more than you want, pasteurized French Brie offers a creamy and mild, buttery flavor familiar to all who have purchased most other well-known brands. This one is a true double creme 60% brie, meaning it is 60% butterfat in dry matter (but 100% brie). Sturdy and economical enough for baking in pastry or slicing for artsy sammies. Light bodied, fruity whites are best for pairing. Read More
  6. Bourbon Bellavitano Quick View

    Bourbon Bellavitano

    $19.99/EA
    This bourbon-bathed beauty is made exclusively for Murray’s by Satori Cheese out of Wisconsin. It tastes like a cross between Cheddar and Parmigiano-Reggiano, with a crumbly exterior and a complex flavor profile revealing creamy, nutty notes. It’s then washed in Kentucky bourbon, infusing a sweet and smoky woodiness on the outside with a strong, milky saltiness on the inside. After the bourbon shower, the cheese is aged for five months until peak flavor is reached. Bright, vibrant and scarce, this labor-of-love is a true specialty. Read More
  7. New Mystic, Melville Quick View

    Mystic, Melville

    $14.99/EA
    Melville is a brand new cheese, from a brand new cheesemaking operation in Mystic, Connecticut, and we’re excited about it. Here’s why you should be, too: a white whale, it’s the rare American super-fresh Stracchino cheese, inspired by the Northern Italian style, which is all about smoothness, pliability and awesome meltability. Melville’s namesake is Herman Melville—homage to the texture of the soft, luxuriously buttery square of cow’s milk cheese. It’s a supple, silky “singularly fatty globule of pure deliciousness,” and a mere few weeks old. It’s a revelation with sweet tomatoes, or atop pizza and pasta, a bottle of Champagne highly recommended. Read More
  8. New Asiago D'Allevo Quick View

    Asiago D'Allevo

    $18.99/LB
    With flavors reminiscent of the fragrances of yeast and dried fruit, this firm raw cow milk cheese starts out sweet and becomes more savory and piquant as it ages. From Italy's Po River Valley. Read More
  9. New Old Chatham Vanilla Yogurt (16 oz) Quick View

    Old Chatham Vanilla Yogurt (16 oz)

    $5.99/EA
    Pure and simple, 100% sheep’s milk. No thickeners, no stabilizers. Live and active pro-biotic cultures and real flavors! Old Chatham yogurt is a specialty item, made with love and made to order! This item will be shipped separately on the Tuesday after you place the order. Trust us, it’ll be worth the wait. Read More

Grid View List View

1-9 of 99

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5