Cheese
-
Quick View
Hudson Valley Camembert
$9.99/EASquare Camembert? Sheep Camembert? American Camembert?!? Oh yes, the upstate flock behind this dense and creamy tile bucks convention with delicious results. Toast them with California Sparkling.
2011 American Cheese Society Winner Read More -
Quick View
St. Marcellin
$7.99/EAWhat a crock. . . of cheese. Rustic and barny, these cozy little discs pick up creaminess and gentle pungency as they develop. Warm in the oven, serve on fresh baguette with a Rhone Red, and be happy. Read More -
Quick View
New York State Cheddar
$7.99/LBIt’s no secret- New Yorkers love cheese. Heck, we’ve even got a museum dedicated entirely to the cheese of New York State - and this hunk of sharp, grassy goodness, full of the same spunk and sass that defines a native New Yorker, serves as an edible monument to the centuries-long history of Empire State cheese. Read More -
Quick View
Red Wax Gouda
$8.99/LBAn old fashioned farmer co-op and a cheesemaker with 40 years of experience in Wisconsin makes this old favorite a hit again, with its extra creaminess and touch of tang. Cheese for the masses indeed. Read More -
Quick View
Black River Blue
$9.99/LBA classic American blue from the North Hendren Cheese Cooperative which has been making cheese for 80 years. The recipe for this blue is well-guarded, and for good reason! The texture is slightly softer than butter- a nice creamy backdrop for the bright blue flavor. Read More -
Quick View
Smoked Gouda
$9.99/LBPerfecting the craft since 1912, Maple Leaf, the Wisconsin farmer cooperative makes a creamy Gouda with real smoky flavor from Hickory. Read More -
Quick View
Ellsworth Creamery
Cheese CurdsPrice From:$5.99/EADisplaced Wisconsinites and snack lovers across the nation have cause to rejoice: fresh from the vat cheddar cheese curds! Read More -
New
Sale
Quick View
Painted Goat Fresh Chevre
Price From:Regular Price: $11.99/EA
Special Price: $9.99/EA
We age a number of our cheeses in our caves to great effect, but Painted Goat boasts the unique distinction of having cave-aged its cheesemaker-- Ilyssa Berg, who handcrafts creamy, grassy goat cheeses in upstate New York with her partner Javier Flores, learned the art of affinage beneath our Greenwich Village store. Read More -
Quick View
Smoked Lioni Mozzarella
$9.99/EAAfter generations, the Lioni family has perfected the moist and delicate curd of their pasteurized cows milk mozzarella. They take it a step further here with a heady treatment of hickory and cherry wood-smoke. Read More
Shop By
Category
- Blue (1)
- Brie & Creamy (3)
- Cheddar (2)
- Fresh & Chevre (9)
- Gouda (1)
- One of a Kind (2)
- Smoked & Flavored (2)
- Best Sellers (1)
- Cave Aged (1)
- Sale (1)
- New (1)
- Vermont Butter and Cheese Creamery (5)
Country
Milk Type
Tell us what you like!
- Blue (1)
- Buttery (3)
- Comforting (4)
- Creamy (2)
- Crowd-Pleasing (5)
- Crumbly (1)
- Decadent (1)
- Delicate (2)
- From Our Caves (1)
- Good for Kids (6)
- Mellow (4)
- Minerally (2)
- Modern (1)
- Silky (2)
- Smoky (2)
- Soft (3)
- Sweet (1)
- Traditional (1)
- Wacky (1)
Rennet Type
Pairings
- Scotch (1)
- Wheat Beers (5)
- Lagers and Kolsch (6)
- Hoppy Beers (1)
- Belgian-Style Ales (1)
- Porters and Stouts (1)
- Malbec (1)
- Merlot (3)
- Syrah and Shiraz (2)
- Tempranillo (1)
- Chardonnay (3)
- Riesling (1)
- Sauvignon Blanc (2)
- Sparkling Wine (1)
- Rose (3)
- Cider (4)
