Cave Aged
-
Cave Aged
Quick View
Isle of Mull Cheddar
$29.99/LBThis cheddar is full of Scottish spirit. The cows are fed mash from a local whiskey distillery, resulting in a cheese that is yeasty and sharp with a boozy prickle. Perfect with single-malt. Read More -
Quick View
Caciotta di Capra con Pepe
$22.99/LBA goat in sheep’s clothing. This caciotta, or “little cheese,” hails from the land of sheep’s milk Pecorino but has a flavor all its own—preserved lemons, brown butter, and the spice of whole black peppercorns. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Pyrenees Brebis
$26.99/LBThe first cheese we called ''compulsively edible,'' and still the best. Once you pop, you can't stop. Read More -
Quick View
Toma Walser
$19.99/LBNEW ARRIVAL! The Walsers were a Germanic people that wound up settling throughout the Alps, including the Piedmont region of northern Italy. This sweet smelling, ivory-colored gem is named for them. Read More -
Quick View
Caciocavallo
$18.99/LBCaciocavallo earns its name, literally ‘cheese on horseback’, from the way duos of gourd-shaped rounds are rope-bound and slung over a wooden board to drain and age. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Fontina Val d'Aosta
$21.99/LBRespect the Matterhorm. Each mountainous wheel is grassy, slightly truffly, and subtly fruity. Regular washing in our caves preserves and develops complex flavor. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Crottin de Chavignol
$5.99/EADropped in our caves as a quiet, unassuming fresh chevre, crafted from pasteurized goat’s milk, Crottin de Chavignol emerges from its lair a changed being... Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Sainte-Maure de Touraine
$16.99/EAOh lovely lemony log, how I delight in your goaty goodness. How I exalt your herbal essence. How I adore your careful Murrays-aging of 2-4 weeks. Read More -
Cave Aged
Quick View
Shop By
Country
- USA (23)
- France (18)
- Italy (8)
- Switzerland (4)
- Spain (4)
- United Kingdom and Ireland (5)
Milk Type
Tell us what you like!
- Blue (3)
- Bold (9)
- Buttery (6)
- Caramelly (2)
- Challenging (6)
- Comforting (3)
- Creamy (7)
- Crowd-Pleasing (9)
- Crumbly (6)
- Decadent (4)
- Delicate (8)
- Earthy (10)
- For a special occasion (7)
- From Our Caves (28)
- Fruity (3)
- Fudgy (6)
- Funky (7)
- Good for Kids (4)
- Gooey (1)
- Grassy (15)
- Herbaceous (5)
- Lingering (11)
- Magical (9)
- Meaty (13)
- Mellow (5)
- Minerally (7)
- Modern (9)
- Mushroomy (5)
- Nutty (11)
- Romantic (7)
- Rustic (11)
- Salty (3)
- Savory (13)
- Serious (5)
- Sharp (2)
- Silky (1)
- Smoky (2)
- Soft (5)
- Spicy (3)
- Stinky (7)
- Subtle yet complex (9)
- Sweet (3)
- Tangy (7)
- Traditional (8)
- Unforgettable (13)
- Velvety (4)
- Wacky (4)
- With a story (6)
Rennet Type
Pairings
- Wheat Beers (9)
- Lagers and Kolsch (10)
- Hoppy Beers (5)
- Farmhouse Ales (11)
- Belgian-Style Ales (16)
- Porters and Stouts (1)
- Strong Beers (4)
- Cabernet Sauvignon (5)
- Pinot Noir (13)
- Malbec (3)
- Merlot (14)
- Syrah and Shiraz (10)
- Chianti (3)
- Tempranillo (2)
- Chardonnay (21)
- Pinot Grigio (5)
- Riesling (12)
- Sauvignon Blanc (8)
- Chenin Blanc (5)
- Rose (9)
- Cider (20)
- Dessert and Fortified Wines (4)
- Scotch (5)
- Bourbon (5)
- Rum (1)
- Fruit Brandies (3)
- Gin (2)
