Cheddar
-
Quick View
Tickler English Cheddar
$16.99/LBWe're not quite sure what a French tickler is, but we're positive about the English one - it's a mature, robust cheddar - aged 18 months to sweet, tangy perfection. Made from raw cow's milk in Devon. Read More -
Quick View
New York State Cheddar
$7.99/LBIt’s no secret- New Yorkers love cheese. Heck, we’ve even got a museum dedicated entirely to the cheese of New York State - and this hunk of sharp, grassy goodness, full of the same spunk and sass that defines a native New Yorker, serves as an edible monument to the centuries-long history of Empire State cheese. Read More -
Quick View
Prairie Breeze Cheddar
$17.99/LBThis award-winning cheddar produced by the Musser family uses milk from local Amish farms, all within 15-miles of the creamery. Sweet and balanced, it's medium sharp and has the nuttiness of an alpine cheese with subtle grassy tones. Read More -
Quick View
Irish Cheddar
$11.99/LBFirm, mild pasteurized cows' milk cheddar. Superb for grating and melting. Read More -
Quick View
Ellsworth Creamery
Cheese CurdsPrice From:$5.99/EADisplaced Wisconsinites and snack lovers across the nation have cause to rejoice: fresh from the vat cheddar cheese curds! Read More -
New
Quick View
Cabot Creamery
Murray's Select Vermont Cheddar$12.99/LBFrom Vermont’s cheddar experts at Cabot, a classic cheddar, just for Murray's. It’s a nutty classic that fits the grill—get it now at this sweet introductory price and it fits the bill, too! Read More -
Quick View
2 Sisters Isabella Gouda
$17.99/LBThis year-old gouda has it all: the dense creamy paste of a younger cheese, and the developed beefy-butterscotchy flavor and light crunch of something much older. Leaves little to be desired, save your favorite beverage pairing. Read More
Shop By
Country
- USA (4)
- The Netherlands (1)
- United Kingdom and Ireland (2)
Milk Type
- Cow (7)
Tell us what you like!
- Buttery (1)
- Caramelly (1)
- Comforting (1)
- Crowd-Pleasing (2)
- Crumbly (1)
- Good for Kids (5)
- Grassy (1)
- Hard (1)
- Lingering (1)
- Meaty (1)
- Mellow (1)
- Salty (1)
- Sharp (1)
- Sweet (2)
- Tangy (1)
- Traditional (1)
Rennet Type
Pairings
- Belgian-Style Ales (2)
- Porters and Stouts (1)
- Cabernet Sauvignon (1)
- Pinot Noir (1)
- Malbec (2)
- Merlot (2)
- Chardonnay (5)
- Sparkling Wine (1)
- Cider (4)
- Scotch (1)
- Bourbon (1)
- Lagers and Kolsch (2)
- Hoppy Beers (3)
- Farmhouse Ales (1)
