Old Chatham

This New York State farm has been producing award-winning sheep’s milk cheese and dairy products since 1993, including favorites like Ewe’s Blue. With fresh milk sourced straight from their farm, Shepherd’s Way, and produced in their state-of-the-art facilities, it’s no wonder that this creamery is renowned for impeccable flavor.

Stock Update: Some items in this category may be temporarily out of stock.
We apologize for the inconvenience! Please check back soon for updates.