• Home
  • Old Chatham Creamery Cupid's Choice 5oz

Old Chatham Creamery Cupid's Choice 5oz

This item is currently unavailable.

Please see similar delicious cheeses like Murray's Mini Brie and Four Fat Fowl St. Stephen.


Among the rolling hillsides of the Hudson Valley, Old Chatham Creamery specializes in soft cheese with a fondness for sheep milk (they shepherd one of the largest flocks in America). Today the farmstead icon presents a bloomy, cow's milk joint inspired by their burning desire to create artisanal handmade cheese for every occasion. (They also have a gift for shaping cheese into the most darling silhouettes!). Heart-shaped Cupid’s Choice is everything we want in a French classic but with a twist. It feels luscious and buttery while tasting of sweet earth. It promises to break hearts once it’s gone. Savor it while you can with Black Cherry Confit and Rustic Bakery Rosemary & Olive Oil Flatbreads for an unforgettable date night bite.

Photos from Our Community

Just the Facts

United States
New York
Milk Type
Rennet Type
10 Days
5 oz